BMW 318 - worst car ever ?

Have a question or want to start a discussion? Post it! No Registration Necessary.  Now with pictures!

Threaded View


After three years of nothing but problems with the wife's 318 I did
something I should have do a long time ago .. traded it in for a Mercedes.
I feel so cheated that I wasted so much time on a car with such poor quality
components and a dealer network with no interest in sorting anything out.
Anyway .. What a difference .. the Mercedes works reliably and the dealer
still has an interest in looking after us and the car.  I'm getting the
feeling that the saying is true that you never actually own a Mercedes ..
you just look after it for the next person.  With the BMW I was just looking
after the dealer bank balance!


I would have through that as the 3 series out sell any other salon in Europe
they would have a product and dealer network that matched there advertising
claims. If BMW want to keep their reputation then they need to work not only
on the quality of their cars but also the manner of their dealers.

That's my moan over so come on BMW not every one of your customers is a
company car driver who does not have to worry about how much things cost to
fix.






Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?




"billy" <nomail> wrote in message


Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?






Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?



What will this lamentation change for Bimmer fans ?

Possibly you got a lemon, possibly you didn't have a strong liking for the
dealer.
Nobody will ever know.

Good luck with your Merc, and rendez-vous on the Mercedes Forum within some
months because I guess you'll have exactly the _same_ problems.

"billy" <nomail> a écrit dans le message news:
3LadncGGatqEvBXYnZ2dnUVZ8s2mnZ2d@bt.com...


Not mine.



After driving  it for 11 years it still ran like a dream.  Finally sold it
over blue book to the first person who drove it.




Re: Not mine.





Yeah, I picked up a 94 318i conv w/ 91K miles last spring, we only put about
8K on it but the car didn't have a problem (other than a collapsing
headliner), rattle or repair.  The previous owner said he had it for about
30K and did nothing but brakes and oil services.



Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?



I am a less than thrilled BMW owner also, have had less than satisfactory
dealer encounters.
People who are extremely satisfied with their version of a manufacturer's
product and people who are at the opposite end of the spectrum should not
automatically assume that everyone else has had the same experience.
All manufacturers of everything, no matter their quality control, will send
out some units with problems. BMW is no different than anyone else and there
are serious issues with some of their products.
Some consumers are never satisfied either . . .
I too wish I had bought a Mercedes, however.



Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?



bmoag wrote:


Merc is not better.  According to CR, Merc is significantly worse, in
fact.


Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?




If you were destined to get a and car you could have got a shitty example
of a Mercedes, too. Yeah I know, that's too zen for this time of the morning. My
bad.

But you're point is well taken, evenry car maker ships bad ones from time to
time.

Except Fords which are all bad.


--
   Need Mercedes parts?   http://parts.mbz.org
Richard Sexton       | Mercedes stuff: http://mbz.org
1970 280SE, 72 280SE | Home pages: http://rs79.vrx.net
633CSi 250SE/C 300SD | http://aquaria.net http://killi.net

Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?



   billy <nomail> wrote:

If you've decided a boring car will suit you better why not go the whole
mile and get a boring *and* reliable car  - a Lexus?

--
*Not all men are annoying. Some are dead.

    Dave Plowman        dave@davenoise.co.uk           London SW
                  To e-mail, change noise into sound.

Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?




Dave Plowman (News) wrote:

Can't get much more boring than a 318.


Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?




Have you driven a recent one? Decidedly lively for a base model with a
sweet engine for a four. Well balanced chassis too - the lighter engine
doesn't do any harm.

--
*If you're not part of the solution, you're part of the precipitate *

    Dave Plowman        dave@davenoise.co.uk           London SW
                  To e-mail, change noise into sound.

Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?




Dave Plowman (News) wrote:

Last one I drove was a 2004 model.  Lively isn't the word I'd use.  A
well balanced chassis makes for a dull ride when the car's got no
ooomph.     It was quiet but that's about the only good thing I could
say about it.


Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?



mate bought one of the first 318 coupes some years ago - nothing but
trouble - air con / electrics/windows/paint (even matt leather one
side/glossy on the other door) etc etc

To cap it all he bought it new in October, when he got the reg. doc  (V5)
the dealer had registered it for a few days in the previous month to hit a
dealer incentive
Mate complained, dealer lost the incentive and then dealer principle had
great pleasure to tell friend when he complained about all the build quality
issues - well it is second hand (with a smirk)

fight ensued!



Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?




lurkio wrote:


Yes I got that, when I was buying a used car it was "we do a thorough
million point check so it comes to you like new"  then a week after
"well it *has* done 30k miles sir"


Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?



waffled on about something:


30k is nothing though, that's like expecting a 20 year old person to
start falling apart!

Even Lada could build things to last longer than that!

Dodgy.
--
MUSHROOMS ARE THE OPIATE OF THE MOOSES

Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?



waffled on about something:


There was always the old 316 :-)

Dodgy.
--
MUSHROOMS ARE THE OPIATE OF THE MOOSES

Re: BMW 318 - worst car ever ?




billy wrote:

I understand how you feel.  Having had a 318 myself, less than stellar
car.  What made matters worse was the lack of care at the dealership.
Granted it was only a 318 and not a 750, but they should have been more
responsible.

I switched to a Cadillac STS after the 318...and like in your case,
what a difference!

Since then I moved to a different state. I am happy that the local BMW
dealer is much better, and I am happy with my X 5.  It too had some
problems, nothing that dealer could not take care of, as a drive in.

Good luch with your Mercedes.  I've had a few of those, including the
6.9!  They are fine cars.

gamini


Site Timeline