Looking for some ideas -
My '89 325i convertible with ~143K mi was fine when I took it to WB Motors, Pickett Rd, in Fairfax VA. They did some simple things - replaced a couple brake hoses, balanced front tires, attached the muffler heat shield, and some bulbs. I went to pick it up, and couldn't put the car in gear. It turns out the 5spd manual is mysteriously stuck in reverse, although the shifter is in the neutral position. They claim it was fine when they drove it out of the shop, and had no idea there was this major damage to the car. They rolled it back in and determined that the external linkages are fine, something is jammed inside the transmission, although somehow the shifter is not in reverse and will not move into any gear.
So first, I wonder what my options are to fight with them about it. They offered 10% off to fix it with a 100K mi used transmission, at $1650 w/ clutch, this was not satisfactory. And my trust was broken with them anyway, so I didn't go ahead with that. Is there any point arguing this?
Towed to next shop closer to home, they confirm the problem, quote $2500, and again can only replace it, not open it up to find the problem. This isn't worth doing on a $2400 car, I think.
I feel like my best option is to get the transmission opened and looked at. Can anyone recommend a transmission place in Northern Virginia that can open up a BMW transmission and possibly fix it?
Thanks!
-Alex