Frustrating charging system issue, 2000 GC

It's a 2000 Grand Caravan 3.3L, high mileage.

The charging system seems to be failing intermittently but increasingly. Things will be fine for several days then I'll get a battery light (low voltage) and then the car will die as the voltage continues to drop.

Replaced battery and checked the entire charging system (passed all tests with alternator putting out good voltage and amps) but ran into the same problem a week later when the new one discharged.

During one of the "events", I measured 11.5V and dropping running at

2K RPM (and only slightly less turned off); took this to be an indication of a bad alternator. Yesterday I took the alternator out (and what a job that is) and brought it to the parts store, where it passed their test with flying colors. Put that alternator back in, cleaned and tightened all battery connections etc. and immediately got 14V into the battery. Hooray.

Of course this morning I am back to the battery light being on and no apparent charging all day (less than 10V upon returning home).

So, after a bit more research, I am left with these possible theories:

  1. Bad body control module -- the voltage regulator is apparently integrated into this computer (!) and if it is bad it could be preventing the charge from reaching the battery.

  1. From a glance at the Haynes book at the store there appears to be an "MDS relay" (I may be misremembering the name here) between the alternator and the battery; no relay by this name appears to be in the main relay center next to the battery and the relays under the dash are unlabeled. If anybody can tell me where to find this relay I can have it checked.

  2. Grounding problem, probably to the computer module. The ground connection to the battery is good; not sure how to proceed with checking this.

  1. Truly bad / intermittent alternator -- I've never heard of one go intermittent in this way; a replacement is a nonrefundable 0 and I hate to shotgun without knowing.

  2. Bad (brand new) battery -- don't think this can be it, since it takes and holds a charge from a battery charger, and runs the car for a reasonable amount of time before dying.

Any other ideas, or ways to narrow this down. I am tearing my hair out here and the cost of sending an electrical gremlin to the shop is scary.

Thanks

JGM

Reply to
jgmclean0
Loading thread data ...

If it stays off all day, it would be an absolute breeze to troubleshoot if you knew how it was supposed to be. Since it works sometimes, that should be easy too. Take some baseline voltage measurements when it is working. Take the same measurements when it's not working.

Using that, it should be extremely easy to isolate the problem at the alternator. In other words, either the alternator is STOPPING or something else is TELLING IT to STOP. You just need to know what each wire on the alternator is for. If you have a shop manual, again, this should be no problem.

I wouldn't pull my hair at all until I'd figured out what component chose to shut down the alternator.

Reply to
Joe

Not sure if it pertains to yours. Some of them the voltage reg is part of the body control computer So I would be checking the computer grounds

Reply to
sqdancerLynn

First of all toss the Haynes manual in the trash can, its wortheless. The BCM does not in any way have control of the generator. When you say the voltage dropped down 11.5 5 did you measure this at the battery or the Gen Batt stud? this would make a big difference as to where the problem may be. If you checked it at the alt stud and it is indeed low I would then check for continuity between the generator field terminal DG wire to the PCM C1 connector pin 8 for a tight fit or broken wire. you may even want to do a wiggle test on this. The other thing to be aware of is if you had an over charge or undercharge condition the Check engine lite should be on setting a fault code. I see no mention of you checking for any faults. Normally if no faults are set the generator is working and the problem would be from the Generator batt stud to the battery. MAKE SURE THE TERMINAL FOR THE GROUND AND B+ ON THE GENERATOR IS NOT BURNED. ALso take a good look at the

40 cartridge fuse in the PDC. for a burned condition that may be causing intermittent contact. This happens alotwith alt. radiator fan and a/c compressor intermittent problems

Glenn Beasley CHrysler Tech

Reply to
damnnickname

oooops one more thing , the relay you are referring to is the ASD relay. make sure that when the engine is running you have 12 volts at the DG/OR wire at the generator connector also. If the generator is not charging...while the engine is running ground the generator field wire DG wire at the generator with a voltmeter at the battery to see if the output rises to 13 or more volts. if the output raises..... then you have an open circuit from the generator to the PCM. if that wire tests good replace the PCM

Glenn

Reply to
damnnickname

Glenn, thanks very much for your response here.

At the battery; not sure how to check it at the alternator.

No check engine lights or fault codes, just the battery symbol light and corresponding voltage measurements at the batt.

The main thing I am getting from this is that I won't get anywhere without a shop manual (or at least the relevant pages from one) since I have no idea where to find these test points. Any ideas how to proceed there?

How is that one labeled? None of the fuse names on the inside cover of the PDC looked promising.

JGM

Reply to
jgmclean0

Where do I find it?

I think I actually understand this procedure, though again I guess I will need a shop manual to know which pins are which.

As a point of interest, how do you actually do these measurements? The connection to the generator does not allow access to the pins even if they could be reached. Perhaps in the shop you have a special jig; how do I do it in the garage?

JGM

Reply to
jgmclean0

I gave you the color of wire that each one represents and the pin number that the wire goes into on the PCM. The PCM connectors are numbered

I dont know why you need a shop manual, once again I gave you the color of each wire and pin number to the pcm and what the voltage should be

If they arent labeled check at least check the ones that say 40amp. if you tap on them with your hand while the engine is running you may see a spark inside the cartridge if there is a problem with one

Reply to
maxpower

Ok, first of all you wont need to find it if you have 12 volts at the generator (Dark green with an Orange tracer wire)

Once again, I gave you the color of the wire and the pin number that it goes into the PCM. No shop manual is needed ESPECIALLY a Haynes Manual

With a DVOM meter

I have no problem with this at the shop, no speacila tools or jigs needed

Reply to
maxpower

Ah. I hadn't parsed DG/OR as a color code. In general I'd be more comfortable doing this with a diagram in hand, but I will give your procedure a try (probably a Saturday morning project at this point).

I thought you were suggesting I measure the voltage at the alternator terminals as well as the input to the PCM, which led to my question as the contact points at the alternator are within a connector and difficult to access anyway.

Thanks again

JGM

Reply to
jgmclean0

If your car has a "shared ground post" connection, i.e. where the neg. battery cable and the other elect. grounds mount to a post on the chassis, read an old post regarding this problem - my sebring was at the dealer for lengthly periods with a similar problem but they couldn't diagnose it.

formatting link
Good luck, Bill.

Reply to
Bill

Just wanted to follow up on this, for the benefit of any future searchers.

The problem did turn out to be the alternator. This is apparently a rare occurence (and in fact the alt had to be special ordered), but after 190K miles I guess it was time. The original alt had become intermittent based upon temperature and vibration, which explains why the first time I took it out it passed the test at the parts store. I had gotten it to the point where I could "activate" the alt after starting the car by tapping the bracket with a hammer; when this got tiring (heh) I bit the bullet and bought the new alternator.

A couple of notes: this is really a tedious alternator to replace. You have to remove the wipers and the entire wiper assembly (including electrical, washer hose, and drain connections, and multiple bolts to release the alt from the bracket. The bracket itself is held to the engine by indeterminate means; I never could find the final bolt to remove the bracket and had to manhandle the bracket out of the way to get the alternator out (and had to remove the coil pack to do that). Dealing with the tensioner and belt routing on this car is always a challenge; be sure you have a belt routing diagram or make one before you remove the belt. Replacing the belt is easier if you remove the wheel and wheel well plastic from the right front. In short, it's well worth any effort to verify the status of the alternator before removing it to avoid having to do it more than once, and it's a stretch job for the DIY mechanic.

The new alternator came with a nice tech note (TT #651 from Publitech Inc.) that concisely explained how to determine if a no-charge condition is actually due to an alternator problem, and included many of the caveats mentioned in this thread (a little late for me but there you go). I suspect that the parts store (in my case Advance) could pull this up for you without having to purchase an alternator.

Belated thanks to all who helped here and via email.

JGM

Reply to
jgmclean0

MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.