Silicone brake fluid - good or bad?

As I said, it's all down to humidity and temperature. I know little about the physics of it, but I do know that warm air can hold more moisture than cold air. Therefore air having a high moisture content will be comparitively warm. If that air is in a contaner, which is then cooled, the air will lose it's abilility to hold as much water in suspension, resulting in some of it condensing on the walls of the container. What that container is made of, doesn't affect the principle.

This is not correct. Every time you brake, air is sucked into the reservoir through the vent hole to replace the same volume of brake fluid used to expand the callipers or cylinders. When the brake pedal is released, the fluid returns, and that same volume of air is vented to atmosphere. So this constant, 'breathing in and out' as you term it, does take place. Resulting eventually in a complete change of air in the reservoir. A trip on a humid day could result in that same humid air filling the air space in the reservoir. Followed by a cold night, moisture in that air will condense on the cold walls of the reservoir.

What fluid is used doesn't make any difference to the degree of condensation that occurs. The only difference is what happens to the water once it runs down into the fluid. In one it's absorbed. In the other it remains as a volume of water. Mike.

Reply to
Mike G
Loading thread data ...

"Mike G" realised it was Sun, 30 Jan 2005

01:55:55 -0000 and decided it was time to write:

I keep reading and hearing about this remarkable phenomenon, but all the 'evidence' is anecdotal. I have never seen badly coroded brake components due to the use of silicone brake fluid. I have seen it plenty of times with glycol-based brake fluid, but never with silicone.

Serious Googling doesn't bring up any first hand experiences, either. Do you have first hand experience of what you describe?

Reply to
Yippee

In article , Mike G writes

Eh? The *piston* replaces the volume of brake fluid used to expand the callipers or cylinders, certainly in the braking systems I'm familiar with ;-)

Reply to
Ben Mack

Ok you are all missing the point on this water thing, its not rust or whatever.

Silicone fluid is not, as someone pointed out, hygroscopic - IE it does not absorb water, which conventional fluids do to a limited but protective extent.

So---water (which will over time get into the fluid in what is NOT a closed system) settles at the lowest point in the brake line system.

Corrosion is not the issue --- Frost is It makes things very interesting when this water plug freezes on a cold winters day.

THATS THE POTENTIAL PROBLEM

and its happened to a few people with predictable results!

Clive

either. Do

Reply to
tby

out, so there is no (or very very little) air interchange. writes

itself, that

after a hot

Reply to
tby

"tby" realised it was Wed, 09 Feb 2005 09:58:07 GMT and decided it was time to write:

But *why* would this water get into a silicone-filled system when the fluid is not hygroscopic?

Reply to
Yippee

I have had Silicone fluid in my TR5 since 1998 (end of rebuild) and it is fine. Had to bleed the clutch once, brakes have not needed any attention.

J.

Reply to
JH

JH realised it was Wed, 09 Feb 2005

22:38:57 +0000 and decided it was time to write:

So, another one with first-hand, positive experience.

Why is it then that none of the nay-sayers seem to speak from their own experience with silicone brake fluid?

Reply to
Yippee

Suggest you look at the manufacturers recommendations for time between complete silicone fluid changes !!!!!

Reply to
tby

"tby" realised it was Sat, 12 Feb 2005 08:45:16 GMT and decided it was time to write:

I suggest you point me to some of those recommendations. I've never seen any.

[integral quote snipped]

Why are you posting upside down? Nobody reads from the bottom up, not even the Chinese.

Reply to
Yippee

MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.