Why is it that the autos manufactured in the UK and Europe achieve better
mileage than those in the US? Here is a like to above 50 mpg autos
available in the UK. Vauxhall (a GM company) has several models in this
Is it gas quality? Emission standards? Other?
I did a quick google search and couldn't find a previous thread discussing
this so thought I'd ask.
I was tempted to believe the engines weren't putting out the hp of US
engines but after driving a Vauxhall Astra that dispelled that belief as it
put any four cylinder car I've driven in the US to shame. (JMO)
First off, those will be imperial gallons (4.54 L), not US gallons (3.78 L),
so 50 miles per imperial gallon is only 41 miles per US gallon. Secondly,
there are a fair number of diesels in there, which aren't available as much
in the North American market, but we do have engines like the VW TDI that
can get that kind of mileage. As well, the cars are generally a fair bit
smaller and lighter, and the engines have correspondingly less displacement,
largely owing to the fact that fuel consumption is much more important
because of the high price of gas in Europe.
As well, the driving cycle being used to measure fuel economy isn't
necessarily directly comparable with the EPA/Transport Canada driving cycles
used to measure fuel economy in North America.
Robert Hancock Saskatoon, SK, Canada
To email, remove "nospam" from email@example.com
Thanks to those that have responded so far.
I forgot the difference in volume measurements. I thought more about it
and also realize that nearly all the driving is not too far above sea level
which equates to better fuel combustion and most of the non-motorway driving
is sub 55 mph.
Some more reasons - many of the extremely small cars over there just
won't pass the safety tests in the states. I don't think they allow a
small car to be "less safe" than a big car - which makes the really
small cars a lot harder to do. Also, for some reason small must equal
cheap. Price goes up per inch over here - so a small car that costs as
much as a big one is a tough sell.
Sky high taxes on motor fuels. Fuel at $5.00 or more per gallon effects
what people can afford to drive.
Note that the highest fuel consumption automobiles in the world also come
from Europe, where they are reserved for the wealthy. Ferraris, V12 MBZ,
V12 BMWs, the Maybach, Rolls Royce, Bentley, Aston Martin, Maserati and more
are all gas guzzlers of the first order. It isn't any moral superiority of
Europeans which has the majority driving small fuel efficient cars, it is
tax policy and economics.
I have an 88 4x4 S-10 that used to get almost 30mpg on long trips. Rubber
floor lining, no A/C no cruise, no power windows, locks, etc 5 speed manual
transmission. I'll bet if it had a nice little diesel and or was a 2wd I
could have hit 35mpg.
Euro cars are half the size, half the weight, half the engine,
and half the power of US cars. In short, half the car.
And they don't have to go very far. In the distance that it takes
me to drive from Houston, Texas to El Paso, Texas I could traverse Europe.
UK gallons are slightly larger than US gallons, as someone else has
noted. But even so, cars in Europe are typically much more fuel
efficient than cars in the US.
People in Europe tend to value fuel efficiency more than people in the
US do, due to high fuel prices. So smaller cars, manual transmissions,
and diesel engines are popular there. Smaller cars are also easier to
park in crowded old cities whose streets existed before cars.
Timothy J. Lee
Motorsforum.com is a website by car enthusiasts for car enthusiasts. It is not affiliated with any of the car or spare part manufacturers or car dealers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.