This should initiate some good debate...
I've always understood that ignition timing should be set with any advance systems (vacuum diaphragm, etc.) disconnected. I tried to set up my '87 Accord that way, and I can't get anywhere near the 20-degree timing mark with the vacuum advance disonnected. Leaving the vacuum line attached, it jumps right close to the 2-degree mark and seems to run well, if missing a little "jump". Oddly enough, when I accidentally took a test drive while forgetting to reconnect the vacuum line, it seem to have a lot better pick-up when I punched the gas...
Anyway, I'm looking in the shop manual... the directions say to disconnect, test, and then plug the vacuum lines, then goes on to list the proper timing settings for various engine/transmission setups, never specifying that one should reconnect the vacuum lines, and describes how to adjust the timing by twisting the distributor. So far so good...
BUT... all the diagrams show the vacuum lines still attached... AND the next step tells how to check the cold-advance operation (on engines that have it), while the following step THEN tells you to disconnect the vacuum hose(s), plug them, and then check the timing with an advance meter, listing way lower advance settings than the previous chart.
Example: the first chart
So what's the story? Experience indicates that timing should be checked and set to 20 degrees (there's an actual "20-degree" mark on the flywheel) WITH the main advance line connected. Old-school knowledge, however, suggests that the line should be disconnected and plugged, but when I do that, it's impossible to get anywhere near 20 degrees (and really, old-school knowledge suggests that 20 degrees BTDC is an
*insane* amount of advance for ANY engine).I've seen this topic generate a lot of debate on a couple boards over which is the proper procedure... just wondering what the concensus is in these parts?