Is it possible to replace the front brake rotors on a 1991 Accord EX without separating the steering knuckle from the lower control arm? Hopefully I can remove the axle nut, and slide the axle out far enough to access the 12pt bolts that secure the hub to the axle, and remove the hubs along with the brake rotors?
I wish. (I have a '91 Accord. With 224K on it, it's had a couple of rotor changes.)
No. The only way to make enough clearance to remove the axle is to separate the lower ball joint first. Either get the right tool (see the service manual) or get a spare boot if you'll use a pickle fork. It helps, but I don't recall at the moment whether it's absolutely necessary, if you also separate the ball joint at the tie rod end. You'll also have to take off the brake caliper and hang it from the strut or spring with a piece of wire. (The Honda service manual is quite good in describing how to go about this.)
Once the axle is out, you can remove the bolts that retain them and the hubs. They can be tapped out fairly easily with bolts the same size as (but longer than) the 12pt bolts that secure them, tapped in rotation to work the hub out of the larger forging. Once they're off, you can unbolt the rotors from the inside (yes, for those who are wondering what this is all about, the inside) of the hubs.
This is one of the dumbest and most aggravating designs I've run across, and I have never understood why Honda did it the way they did. Why they could not bolt the rotors to the outside of the hub like most is beyond me. Even GM knows better!
because, as has been revealed on all subsequent accords and the fact that honda now specify that the disks get machined every time the pads get replaced, honda's lightweight hubs are sensitive to local distortion where the wheel clamps on, and subsequently cause brake juddering. if the brake disk is mounted independently, as is the case with yours, and thus doesn't get subject to torque variance, corrosion trapped under the wheel interface, etc, then the effects are much reduced.
as a rule, gm use much heavier [and thus stiffer] hubs.
if you have this brake problem on a honda, before you machine your disks, scrape off rust, use some anti-seize on the interface, and the correct lug nut torque sequence/process and this problem can be cured. most shops don't know/can't be bothered to do this, hence since "machining" involves cleanup, the fact that the problem disappears is mis-attributed to the cutting operation, not the cleaning. google this group got more details. works on many other vehicles too.
There are others who use lightweight hubs with much more serviceable methods of disk attachment. BMW, VW, and Nissan come to mind. What are they doing differently? (Well, BMW specifies new rotors for every pad replacement on newer cars, but I mean in general.)
What brake problem are you referring to?
One set of rotors simply wore past the minimum. One set was trashed when the pads wore to the backing (don't ask). A third set was replaced when a (less than year-old) caliper seized and warped a rotor and the other was worn enough that I wanted to replace the set.
MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.