'My point isn't the absolute number of miles, that will likely vary by vehicle and by severe vs. normal service. My point is that the manufacturer's recommendation for the type of driving you do is typically fairly conservative. There is simply no need to perform maintenance more frequently than required.'
REPLY: My point is that you canNOT trust the Manufacturer's advertised maintenance claims ; which is why I change my fluids more often myself using all synthetics...except for the Trans Flush/Drain which i have a local shop perform. Ive seen the condition of fluids after the Manufacturers suggested maintenance schedule...and its rediculous pushing it to that extreme.
'Its 'not wasting money' when the manufacturer is pushing it to the limit on maintenance durations to make the vehicle (and them) look good.
And how do you know this? Are you a transmission designer?'
REPLY: I am an avid reader of Technical Articles written by Authoritys in various mechanical fields in addition to having worked in a related Mechanical Trade for over 30 years at a maintenance/teardown/rebuild level. Car Manufacturers, like Car Dealers, cannot be 100% trusted to give the correct story when it comes to maintenance...in addition to design in many cases.
'Common sense is very often wrong. '
REPLY: Common sense which comes from a mechanically oriented person , is usually right. Especially if that person has had first hand experience from a design, application, and repair standpoint.
'Transmission fluid isn't like engine oil. It doesn't see contaminants from combustion that form the nasty acids and such that make the life of engine oil fairly short. Unless you are towing or really abusing your automatic, the only thing the oil has to deal with is wear material from the transmission itself. With a good filter, this isn't a problem for many, many miles. I've never seen a transmission filter even close to being clogged even after 50,000 miles. The other issue for the fluid is heat, but again is is rarely a problem unless you are towing. And then the manufacturer's change intervals are typically a lot shorter. '
REPLY: Automotive Transmission Oil OFTEN SEES contaminants in the form of metal particulates, acidity, and condensation . And heat IS OFTEN a problem in modern auto Transmissions especially in hot climates and/or mostly city driving where the clutches are constantly shifting ; heavy cargo loads or people loads contribute to the issue. Go to
formatting link
for further education on this subject.
'So, realistically compare your driving environment to the description in the maintenance section of your owner's manual, select the appropriate maintenance schedule, follow it, and you'll be fine. No need to do things twice as frequently, unless you like wasting money and time.'
REPLY: And keep in mind that 100,000 mile suggested changing of fluids, spark plugs, and coolant...come from Manufacturers who very often have an ulterior motive .
____________________________________________ "The only thing necessary for evil to continue, is for good (tolerant) men to do nothing" -- C.S. Lewis. ____________________________________________