I have a 2000 tj sport, 4.0L engine, manual transmission with 99000 miles and maintained consistently. Here are my observations:
Jeep still with motor running + neutral + accelerator pressed = normal vroom.
Jeep in motion + neutral + accelerator pressed = normal vroom
Jeep in motion + any gear (1,2,3,4,5) + accelerator pressed = some kind of helicopter noise. This noise seems to get progressively louder as the gears move up.
Jeep in motion + any gear + coasting (no acceleration) = no noise.
Any ideas?