My original valve cover on my 83 CJ7 with 258 engine had been leaking. I removed it to find that it was pretty hammered, kind of looked warped and the holes in the top were cracked, and it had several RTV patches from a previous owner, and was missing a few bolts. So I replaced it with a new (literally never used) plastic cover that I had laying around from a spare engine I have. The new cover did not have the same holes in the top, but found bolts to replace the missing ones and it seemed to fit right. I used a cork felpro gasket, cleaned up the engine extremely well, used gasket cement to hold it to the engine block, then a thin coat of silver/gray RTV to hold the cover on. Torqued it down gently, starting in the middle. Then let it set for 24 hours before I started it. Well now it leaks much worse!
I need to do the job again, but what should I do different this time? Buy an aluminum cover? A different gasket? Not use RTV at all? RTV both sides? What has worked for you?