Reliable long-term P38 -- does it exist?

I have a horrible feeling that my RRC 200Tdi is approaching the end of its life. I should have followed advice from some members of the group (of course you know best!) but instead I've spent a lot of money to get to this stage (transfer box, propshaft, brakes, etc. etc. and replacement engine two years back). Anyway, despite big spending I still have drive-train vibration which, it seems, can only be identified and cured by replacing one expensive component after another, which seems to be a mug's game.

Looking on Ebay, *apparently* sound Classics are becoming thin on the ground, and I'd assume that they will all end up with the same problems as mine in the long run. I don't need seven seats and I like Range Rovers so I'm not that keen on moving in the Discovery direction This leads me to the question: is there such a thing as a reliable, long-term P38? As my only car and daily driver, it would have to be a diesel.

I know that the standard response is "no", but I'd welcome any comments based on personal experience rather than hearsay. I would have a modest budget so would be looking at the lower end of the DSE market, and I don't suppose that will help in terms of reliability :- ( I'm also keen to understand whether the P38 problems are to do with irritations like the toys not working, or show-stoppers like ABS, air suspension, etc.

All views welcome, but again I'd be really interested in direct personal experience. Thanks very much.

Reply to
Andrew
Loading thread data ...

I have had two of 'em & love the things, ok they have problems, but so what.

The main things are air suspension which can be sorted with coils, petrol engines can go west, electronics can be a bit iffy & a few other bits.

Tons of cheap parts available for them now & they don't rust (apart from bottom lip of lower tailgate)

Reply to
Nige

I skipped the P38 completely after two RRC which we owned for a great many years. I too was not instantly attracted to the Disco. I found a mint ES Spec auto on LPG, we ran it for 5 years or so making several trips across France with the caravan in tow. Go and try one. You will find the trim similar, if you don't need 7 seats all the better you may find a cheaper DII.

The only reason I'd say the P38 may have any edge is if you need a tailgate. Otherwise do yourself a favour. Why risk it , you've spent on the RRC and a P38 isn't confidence inspiring.

The RR3 is a different bag of spanners but then they aren't all that cheap yet either.

Lee D

Reply to
Lee_D

MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.