Vauxhall Tigra Alternator?

About a month ago, I was driving on the motorway when my alternator light came on. Then the ABS, and airbag and some other light. Then about 15 mins, they all went out. Took it to a vauxhall dealer, had a full service, and apparently nothing wrong with the alternator.

Two days ago, the alternator light came on and off. Then the stereo just went off. Stopped the car, and couldn't restart it until about a dozen attempts later. Got it running onto the motorway when all the electrics suddenly died. The recovery reckoned its the alternator. I'm inclined to agree. Are we correct? The battery's also brand new.

If it is the alternator, how much is it to replace at the garage? I've managed to find a new one online for 55 quid, and probably cheaper on ebay.

Thanks

Reply to
Benjai
Loading thread data ...

I'll tell you what it probably is. The alternator includes diodes and similar that prevent overvoltage and stuff like that. If the diode has blown, you have a voltage problem, e.g. discharging back through the diode when it's off, and that. The alternator may be fine when running, e.g. normal voltage. A host of faults that boil down to a 10 pence diode result in the whole 50 quid alternator being replaced.

As your description covers "while running", it may be over voltage, or as a possible alternative, it may be some major issues with the wiring loom. Looms can short out all over the shop as well. And this can cause the diodes, etc, to blow out. So replacing the alternator may not solve the underlying problem, although it may.

This is a recurring theme, by the way, nobody seems to diagnose cause any more, they only determine how many large chunks of the machine to replace, there's a lot of motherboards with duff capacitors which have been thrown for the cost of a soldered in capacitor, 15 pence and a minute with a steady hand and a soldering iron. This becomes far more true of cars with EMS and similar, the garage won't try to find out what's really broken when replacing the whole engine control computer will solve it, and cost them nothing more than your wallet. Cynical, I realise.

Reply to
Sales!

Try to find an auto-electrics chap near you. They often live in grease-coated hovels full of ancient alternators and starter motors and they'll fix broken ones really cheaply - £12 for my last one.

Si

Reply to
Mungo "two sheds" Toadfoot

MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.