Car magazine did a test of a hybrid petrol/electric Mclass with a diesel
Mclass running across the USA. There was not a great deal in it but the
diesel won in economy and running cost. This was only a couple or three
Yes, very similar complex technology and hardware to a petrol engine version
but much simpler than a petrol/electric hybrid.
FWIW the previous Mercedes diesel engines [the four, five and straight six
CDi] have not got the best reliability record in the industry, but then
neither have the rest of the car.
These days the diesel goes for 15000 miles between oil changes and this is
likely to increase soon, possibly to double or 30,000 miles or 2 years. They
have already got the oil specification finalised for this service life and
other brands already run well established 30,000 mile oil change intervals,
which obviously needs ultra low sulphur fuel to be possible.
It surely depends on the driving experience and the economics where you are.
You do not know any of this yet so I cannot see how you form an objective
opinion. You have an opinion, yes, but not an objective one based on
economics and experience of the product. When the diesel cars are available
where you are, you may well find that your initial opinion is correct, or
On the whole I would have to say Toyota.
Nissan also have fairly bomb proof engines. Also Honda if driven fairly hard
None are 100% reliable.
Top three appear to be Japanese.
Individual engines designs within a brand might differ or vary in
Perhaps for the last 5-10 years, I'd find it very hard to believe for anything
older than that. The two Hondas I've had took quite a
bit of abuse, one I ran out of water with and drove until choked, but was OK
after. Perhaps greater tolerances in the design or
Aren't the recent ones from Renault? (or at least the top end ones)
Oh yes. I have experience with many older Japanese and European vehicles and
the quality and longevity of things like track rod ends and suspension
bushes is so much better on the Japanese brands. European brands and built
vehicles may well have caught up by now, as they have to, but I have no
proof of this yet personally.
There is a certain amount of cross pollination. I think the Micra diesel has
a Renault sourced engine. Nothing wrong with that if it raises Renaults game
and quality, which has already improved by leaps and bounds over the last
twenty years. They produced some good little cars before that mind you,
thinking of the 4 and 5.
Neither have I found either drivetrains or bodies to be of a lower standard.
If fuel sulphur was reduced then you might. Is there a demand though?
Perhaps your petrol is cheap enough that economy is next to unimportant?
Maybe your petrol storage rules allow anyone to store petrol at their home
in bulk or your fuel stations are all conveniently two minutes down the
Motorsforum.com is a website by car enthusiasts for car enthusiasts. It is not affiliated with any of the car or spare part manufacturers or car dealers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.