When I bought my 2001 CLK430 (used) the dealer had installed 2 new tires on
the front. The fronts were Michelin Pilot Sports , and the rears were Pilot
Sport SX, both Z rated.
The rear tires now need to be replaced but some tire dealers tell me I
cannot put a different brand on the rears - to do so would cause handling
Yet other tire dealers say it doesn't matter and will willingly sell and
install other brand tires.
I would think that as long as I keep the correct sized tires and correct
speed rated on the front and the correct sized tires and correct speed
rated on the rear there should be no problem.
Any opinions? Who is correct? Do I need to buy 2 or 4 tires.
Tires need to be matched pairs, the same on both sides in the
front, and the same on both sides in the rear. If someone is telling
you that they need to sell you four tires, then that is because THEY
need to SELL you four tires, not that you need them.
I mixed fronts and backs once; maybe there are some tires you can do this with
but it made my car ill handling and dangerous. Perhaps MB's in general, but
my car (126) in particular is very sensitive to wrong tires. Use 4 the same
or prepare to die.
Usenet special: on cases of any filters for BMW: http://u.bmwz.org
http://www.mbz.org | Mailing lists: http://lists.mbz.org
Each axle must have a matching pair... so yes, you can have two different
makes as long as you have two pairs of matching tires. This is basic.
Now, performance wise, you have two different traction characteristics and
does not work together... a pair may have a better traction than the other
pair... so your handling is reduced to the weaker pair.
Normal driving... you are fine... If you do performance driving, then you
are better off a matching set.
re - your last point: Not necessarily - how many 'fast' cars have differing
width/profile tyres on the front/rear? Quite a few. :)
Also on a rwd car the requirement for what the tyre does is quite
different, the front will be exposed to alot more lateral force, and the
rear more longitudinal (sp?).
No... that's not what I meant in staggered set (rear tire is way wider than
front). These are for performance car that are designed for it.
You see... MB and BMW are very close to or exactly 50/50 weight
distribution. So that means each tire has the same amount of weight on it or
close to... and 4 tires each has same amount of work/traction to do.
Now if you put two different tires... let's just do it wildly... an
excellent performance tire... and a crappy passenger tire... you know what
is going to happen... car is going to handle very poorly because 50% of your
traction all relies on your crappy tires.
Now, let's get back to reality... he is going to put all performance tires
but two different brands... each performance tire has different
characteristics... remember how when you change all your tires and you
notices such a profound difference from old set to new set? That is what I
meant. They all have their own characteristics...
;freom no problem to "be prepared to die" maybe this is what I should have
asked. I cannot believe the difference in opinions. I guess I have changed
cars before I needed tires in the past, except for my '98 Corvette. All 4 of
these tires wore out about the same and I replaced all 4 for that reason.
Even tire dealers have different opinions about putting different brands
(same speed rating, correct sizes).How can there be so much difference.
Given that there may be a diference in traction, putting different brands on
the front/back, I still cannot believe it is life threatening as many state.
My car came from the Mercedes dealer with different tires on the front/rear.
Crossing the street can be life threatening, and many have died doing it,
but we all still cross streets.
I guess I will buy 4 new tires but I am not convinced there is such a
problem that the car will be unhandleable.
How about some real life experiences.
yes put some real grippy ones up front
and some so so M & S tires on back
hit the exit ramp at speed, hit the brakes
and tell me were your front end ends up.
more fun in the rain
you need to be educated and that you not get at a tire dealer like Sears
go to a performance tire dealer, the place that has the 100K cars out
Yep! Mixed the fronts and rears once. Was terrible! Dad ratted kar would only
drive backwards on a regular street, but would go forewards when I wanted to
park. So I just shipped the thing to England and it works quite nicely there!
mcbrue goodorderedly under the bridge in the trailer down by the river
Motorsforum.com is a website by car enthusiasts for car enthusiasts. It is not affiliated with any of the car or spare part manufacturers or car dealers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.