I'm going to replace my '97 E320 with 38K miles and am trying to decide between two M-B models; I'd keep the "winner" for about five years - the duration of its warranties. Looking for safety and comfort from a car whose (costly) complexity will be covered by a warranty.
I found a 16 month old '04 S430 with 13K miles for about $60K. Included is 68 months of M-B extended warranty coverage. 275 HP V-8, seven speed automatic - 4000 lb car. Has front and side air bags and side head curtains, also lots of options: Parktronic, Xenons, drive dynamic ventilated seats, chestnut wheel and trim etc. S class cars come with heat reflecting glass and laminated UVA reducing side windows, a consideration in California. Its Desert Silver (gold) - is not a great color - however, this car has an attractive interior. A new S class will be offered in '06 so there's an aspect of almost instant obsolescence with this '04 - although I prefer its style to that of the more athletic E class and soon to be shown '06 S class.
The other choice is to buy a new '06 E350 built exactly to order. It would have the new 3.5L 24 valve 268HP V-6 (3600 - 3700 lb car) and a seven speed automatic. I'd order it with ventilated leather seats, keyless go, tire pressure monitor and a wood and leather steering wheel. No sun roof. Has front and side air bags and side head curtains. But it lacks heat reflecting glass and UVA reducing laminated side glass. This would probably cost about $55K to $57K with a 12 month warranty extension - to 5 years.
As a variation, I'd consider the E320 CDI diesel if its then sold in California.
As far as I can determine the used S430 would cost about 15% to 20% more to own and operate than a new E class car - a consideration but not critical to the decision. (The E class depreciates fewer $, is slightly less costly to insure and run.)
If you were about 60, and retired, which one would you choose?
Thanks for your opinions.
Tom