Such a thing as to much cold air?

I've been toying with the idea of leaveing the bumpers off my gti and meshing the hole left behind, but as you can see:

formatting link
That leaves the rad really exposed, plus under bonnet temps will, no doubt plummet... i've also located a mocal oil cooler.

Would I be force feeding her to much air do you think? Leading to the engine dropping below optimum operating temps? I mean while thrashing it i'm sure it will be ok, but during the winter I forsee it could be a bit of a problem.

I suppose i will have to run it and see how she copes when I stick it all back together, and if it does struggle I have a couple of smaller mk2 rads I can try.

Reply to
REMUS
Loading thread data ...

No such thing as too cold intake air. If the stat controls engine temps, so if the enging starts to run cold, fit a stat from a car intended for a colder temp, they open at higher running temps to keep the car running better. Or fit a higher triggered fan temp switch and a decent coolant temp gauge if you don't want to mess with the stat opening temp. If you amke changes monitor it.

Reply to
Sleeker GT Phwoar

sweet idea! i think it'll affect aero dynamics more than anything myself but then the glof is about as aero dynamic as an old volvo :) i think it'll be fine myself but as sleeker says best monitor it!

if you wanna change the temp you could fit a scoop and stick a fan underneath? the MR2 is slightly different but a few people have engine lid fans fitted, i hate the noise they make but there pretty light and can bring the temp down by as much as 10 degree's!

formatting link

Reply to
Vamp

Surely it'd be better not to block off the vents like that and replace them with fans, rather just have the fans as an addition to the vents.

Rogue are really doing well for themselves though, good on them.

Reply to
fishman

ermm the fans are underneath the vents? i dunno what you mean? lol

you can see better in this pic

formatting link

Reply to
Vamp

yeah there doing some good shit, well helpful people too!

Reply to
Vamp

Might suprise yout o know that a mk2 golf has a drag coefficency rateing of

0.34, but you do raise a valid point

I might louver the bonnet if I can find a place that does it for a reasonable price, or go for carbon/fibre glass since they are alot cheaper than i intially thought... but its pie in the sky atm.

Reply to
REMUS

It shouldn't providing your thermostat works.

Your heater takes a lot of heat from the cooling system if you run the interior ventilation fan at a high speed...

Reply to
DervMan

The Cd is only part of the story. What's the frontal area?

Hmmmmmm pie.

Reply to
DervMan

If it suffers from cold in winter, surely the traditional solution of a bit of cardboard/plastic/foil in front of some of the rad is entirely adequate.

(not sure what Vamp's on - his solution seems to be to increase the airflow, which would be the opposite of what you're after)

cheers, clive

Reply to
Clive George

The thermostat will take care of the engine temp. Leave the bumpers on, you'll be glad you did if you clip a tyre wall while doing a track day. Not sure to what extent but doesn't the front bumper help secure the chassis legs together?

Reply to
Homer

i was thinking better air flow (mainly for the engine) followed by reducing the heat a bit to be a good thing?

Reply to
Vamp

If your engine is suffering from excess heat, yes. But if you read what remus actually wrote (quoted above), he's worrying about doing this a little too much and overcooling the engine. Ie the opposite problem to the one you're solving.

cheers, clive

Reply to
Clive George

Nope it utilises 4 bolts that are used to secure it though, it doesn't actually serve a purpose except for cosmetics and wind deflection.

Reply to
REMUS

ahhhhh i see now silly me eh :)

Reply to
Vamp

I mean look at all the blanked off space around the fans, that should be empty so the whole vents are exposed and the fans should just sit there in addition to the vents rather than adding all that blanking surround. surely if the fans conk out temps will go up.

Reply to
fishman

I think it's a good point. You'll have a lot more engine bay air-turbulence with a massive hole in the front. It'd work better if you blanked off the front rather than mesh it (or, erm put a bumper back on), plus to be honest I really think that would be faaar too much open space - you'll be able to see right into the engine!

or..

my god no.....

you're not thinking of putting neons in there, are you?

;)

Chris.

Reply to
Chris B

I suppose I could create a template and get a thin section of metal laser cut to fit, it would be more difficult to secure but it might be worth it.

But when taking into consideration aero-dynamics, having a metal plate on the front could create more wind resistance than the negative drag of turbulence increased by the meshed area. Unless of course I can angle it to deflect the oncoming air more economically without it looking out of place. I could also combine both ideas... but I run the risk of over complication.

*strokes chin*

now that's a plan!

I'm trying to lighten the golf and not much else!

Reply to
REMUS

I'm not an expert on aerodynamics, but IMO it would be worse to have a lot of turbulence running around the engine bay. If there is a flat section at the front of the car, air will be deflected around it and not much else. The frontal area that hits the air won't be massive. However, if you allow the air to flow straight into the engine bay, it'll have to move around the engine and hit the back of the engine bay, which has a much greater surface area. I suppose it could deflect under the car, but I still think it would create quite a bit more drag. I would try to keep the mesh section to just in front of the radiator, and block off the rest (if possible).

If you're dead set on a mesh right across the front though, I see no harm in trying it out just to see if it really makes a difference.

You could fit it with radio control, so you don't need a heavy driver in there ;)

Chris.

Reply to
Chris B

i wouldnt have thought the drag would make much difference until you hit, say illegal speeds?

Reply to
Theo

MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.