Far be it from me to rehash old threads, (yeah, right) but I was just flipping through a Consumer Report mag and read this little blurb under "Myth Busters" beside an article on bettering fuel mileage. I don't remember who said what, but CR says this:
"A dirty air filter. Our tests show that driving with a dirty air filter no longer has any impact on fuel economy as it did with older engines. This is because modern engines use computers to precisely control the air/fuel mixture."
Now *I* still think a clogged filter will make the engine work harder, but apparently it would have to be *REALLY* clog to make a noticeable difference in your fuel mileage.