Carbon Footprint Emissions: Prius vs Volt vs Leaf

summary:

A Department of Energy study found that depending on which electrical utility region an electric or plug-in hybrid recharges from the carbon footprint of the electricity provider to generate the electricity could be more than the carbon footprint generated by a regular gas-electric hybrid like the Toyota Prius. The Western part of the USA, especially the Northwestern USA states, is where electric and plugin hybrids would generate less carbon dioxide emissions than a regular hybrid. However, in the Mid-Atlantic states and the Upper Midwest States, a regular hybrid like the Toyota Prius would have a smaller carbon foot print than an all-electric car like the Nissan Leaf. In New york, Ohio, Illinoise, and the Southeastern states a regular hybrid(like the Toyota Prius), would have a smaller carbon foot print than an all electric car (like the Nissan Leaf) OR a plugin hybrid (like the Chevy Volt).

analysis/commentary:

Carbon foot print cause by electricity used by a Plugin or All Electric vehicle is very low if the electricity is generated by hydroelectric, solar, geothermal or wind power. Electric power generated by nuclear power would have a radioactive waste foot print (which is not identified in the source story). The source story identifies electrical utility regions where electricity is mainly generated by using coal/natural gas/diesel (fossil fuels) inwhich the electricity used by a EV or PHEV would indirectly generate a carbon dioxide footprint.

source: The Dirty Truth about Plug-in Hybrids: How green is that electric car? Depends on where you plug in. Michael Moyer. Scientific American. July 2010. Vol. 303. Number 1. page 54-55

Reply to
Neo
Loading thread data ...

MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.