Prius cold weather performance has been the straw most often grasped by hybrid skeptics. The 1.5L Prius take pains to minimize emissions and engine warm-up and this burns more gas, often inefficiently. Worse, at high power settings, the 1.5L engine uses fuel enrichment to avoid burning out the catalytic converter. It didn't take long for petroleum addicts, petrodicts, to decide this would be their 'hook' for Prius critical articles.
The first I remember was a Car and Driver article that decided the middle of winter was the perfect time to do a highway, comparison drive between a Prius and Jetta diesel. A more blatant effort was the "Green Human" Portland-to-Portland, 8,000 mile, cross-country USA drive between a 1.5L Prius and Jetta diesel. But in the end, there was only a 0.5 MPG difference between the larger, roomier Prius and the compact Jetta. Even now, hybrid skeptics trot out the 10 F blizzard on the highway as their metric for Prius performance as if that is the only metric that counts.
Now the 1.8L Prius introduced two technologies that directly address cold-weather and high-power performance:
About three years ago, we had a record setting, cold air system come to Dixie when I needed to drive to South Carolina to buy a failed traction battery. The high pressure center was over Atlanta, midway in my trip. I left at 4:00 AM, 15F and by the time I reached Atlanta, it had not reached freezing. It wasn't until 2:00 PM when the temperature finally reached 37-38F. I picked up the traction battery and by the time I returned home at midnight, it was back to 18F.
I kept my speed constant 65 mph on the highway and measured the mileage over different temperature ranges only to find later that the mileage followed the air density as a function of temperature. The highest milege was 49-50 MPG at 37-38F and 65 mph. Other segments were down as low as 34-35 MPG solely due to the higher air density of cold air.
The 1.8L Prius could be improved with variable, cooling air inlet vanes. But compared to the 1.5L Prius, it is substantially improved with exhaust warmed coolant and cooled exhaust gas recirculation. We see this in the average mileage owners report for the 1.8L Prius over the earlier 1.5L Prius. Petrodicts are left with crying over the 1.5L Prius in a 10F blizzard.
Bob Wilson