1998 SL2 - Snow tire noise with summer tires

We have a 1998 SL2 with 105,000 miles. We put snow tires on it last fall for our kid's year at college. Now it's back and has summer tires on it.

But now it sounds like there are coarse tread tires, it rumbles, with pitch going up as speed goes up. Any ideas? It is loud enough to need earplugs at highway speeds.

Thanks!

Reply to
somebody
Loading thread data ...

Have you had the alignment checked on all four wheels? Other possibility is that it's a wheel bearing or CV joint that's going. Same noise when in neutral and coasting? Any different on a right or left turn?

Who changed the winter to summer tires? Loose lugnuts?

Reply to
Oppie

It quiets down on left turns and is louder on right turns.

Neutral/coasting doesn't make a difference.

I will check the CV jo>Have you had the alignment checked on all four wheels? Other possibility is

Reply to
somebody

It sounds like a left-hand wheel bearing. Check to see if it pulls to the left on a level road, with properly-inflated tires.

Reply to
Orval Fairbairn

snip to correct top posting

Conventional wisdom suggests left wheel bearing if noise increases during right turns, but YMMV. I recently had a bad wheel bearing where noise increased when turning towards the bad side. After removing the wheel and brakes there was no noise or looseness/play. Diagnosis was made by elimination after replacing the other side first and confirmed only after replacing the second side. Search Google groups for my complete repair report posting.

Good luck, YMMV

Reply to
Private

It doesn't look to difficult and the part is cheap enough:

formatting link
Is this something where the other bearing is almost shot, too?

Reply to
somebody

You are right -- I misread the problem. Yes -- a noisy left wheel bearing should get noisier on right turns; a bad right wheel bearing should make noise on left turns. The car should also pull toward the bad wheel on a straight, level road, with no crosswind.

Reply to
Orval Fairbairn

It's the driver's side front wheel bearing. You can get it replaced at a place like Les Schwab or Midas.

Reply to
David T. Johnson

formatting link

Not necessarily. My experience is that the driver's side lasts about twice as long as the passenger side, probably because most of the miles are with only a driver. The Saturn front wheel bearings seem to wear out a little sooner than on most cars...probably because the design puts a lot of stress on them. I get about 80,000 miles on the driver's side and 160,000 miles on the passenger side front bearings. I've never had to replace the rear wheel bearings so maybe that's compensation.

Reply to
David T. Johnson

Here's a trick that works with most mail/news programs to keep links from fragmenting. copy the link as normal go to target message and start with a quote " paste the link Add another quote " followed by a space .

This should preserve the link in its entirety. "

formatting link
" Let's see if it makes a liar out of me...

Reply to
Oppie

I suspect that you were and are correct that it is most likely a bad left wheel bearing. The Saturn wheel bearing is a double row ball bearing and I suspect it is normally the outer row which is the most heavily loaded in an opposite turn so will both wear and sound louder when turned away from the bad side bearing and often quieter when turned toward the bad side of the car.. On my most recent failure (left side wheel), I suspect that it was the inside ball row which failed which resulted in it being noisier when turned left (towards the bad wheel). I did not cut the old bearing apart to see.

JMHE and .02, YMMV

Reply to
Private

If the OP is considering a DIY repair I recommend reading my earlier reports of this job.

formatting link
job report is here
formatting link
copy & paste the URL address manually.

Just my .02, Good luck, YMMV

Reply to
Private

MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.