My '99 Forester has had it's heat shield tightened twice and it is still rattling at >3000 rpm. The dealership tells me the rattle is very common in Subarus and is difficult or impossible to fix. They want to remove it, claiming it is only to prevent grass fires when off-roading. I figure it also acts as a rock-guard for the exhaust.
I don't take it off road but it sees lots of winter weather and has had plenty of rocks strike it at highway speeds.
Is this a common problem? Is the heat shield impossible to secure? Is the heat shield a trivial part?
Any experience would be helpful, Thanks WW