Hello, How about some hypothetical thinking . It seems to me that the VW would cool a lot better , or easier, if the cold air entered the bottom . Using scoops. and gravity. On redesigned cylinder tins. Went up through the fins. Through the fan or not. And out the vents or through the decklid if it had a bunch of cooling slots in it . Forward movement would drive the cooling air through the engine bay. My background is aircraft engines. Some big honkers too. 2000 cubic inch air-cooled babies. Hot air naturally wants to rise. It would circulate cooling air upward. Driving would be easy enough. The fan would be needed for parked and running. Or traffic. Think gravity furnace.
The downside I can see. As with aircraft engines. Is . There's going to be a lot of dirty air flowing through the engine bay. Road dust and crap. And of course the fan needs redesigned to run backwards probably. Or maybe a different setup mounted on the deck lid. Blowing out. I didn't think that far.
Don't get me wrong. I'm no engineer. if you want to argue, Well, you are right then. And the VW is proven. My point being the tin seals are critical. Why. Because hot air doesn't want to go down. It has to be forced down. You don't put your furnace in your attic for a good reason. I can see when the car is moving getting airflow under the car pulling heat out. But still. Apparently its not enough.
The upside. I'm betting the additional heat on top helps the engine run better when its cold. It might heat the carb faster. I'm betting the tin seals wont matter as much. I'm betting the engine cools a lot better. I'm betting the interior wont get any more heat though. Unless you shoot some straight up through the deck behind the rear seat.