The other day I had problems starting it up, had to repeatedly crank many times. a couple of time I heard the engine kind of "lock up" abnormally, stalling the starter motor temporarily, then while still holding the starter engaged, it pulled on through the locked/stalled condition and continued to crank. After this happened a couple of times, then the starter would no longer rotate the engine, you just hear it spinning, as if there is no load on the starter at all. It sounds like the bendix/relay isn't pushing the starter pinion out any more....or the pinion got stripped out. I tried jumping the battery from another car in case it was low voltage causing the problem, but it does the same thing. So I pulled the starter out, but the pinion looks fine. I connected it to a jump-starter and checked it, it operates fine...the pinion gear pushes out all the way, and it spins up fine. I put a ratchet on the damper and manually rotated the engine and flywheel all around, watching the flywheel teeth. They look fine. The engine sure isn't seized up, although it sounded that way before the starter failed entirely. It rotates easily with a ratchet, and the crankshaft is okay since the flywheel is turning. So I don't see why the starter is not turning the engine over....unless maybe under load the starter is slipping. Maybe the pinion is loose and slips under load? Do automotive shops have some way to dynamically check a starter? Ideas what's wrong?
- posted
19 years ago