I purchased a new GTI in April. I truly have nothing but praise for the car as the only quibbles I had have all but disappeared.
The only delivery problem with the car was the sunroof. Turned out to be a broken clip, and the dealer repaired it under warranty.
The car is exceedingly well designed. I've found the seats (leather) to be supportive and very comfortable for short or long drives. The controls are mostly intuitive, and I have little problem with them. My only quibbles are the sunroof control is unlit (unlike all the other knobs!) and the center console creaks when I rest my arm on it.
It's built for four people, although the carrying capacity says 5. There is AMPLE cargo room, and it handles most loads well.
The handling of the car is phenomenal. I have an aggressive driving style and this car is easily it's equal. With the optional ESP program it is well nigh impossible to put the car out of shape in rain or dry weather (I'll let you know how it handles in snow in a few months. I suspect I'm going to have to purchase a set of 16" rims and Blizzaks for winter.)
The turbo is a little weak in the warm weather.
The Monsoon stereo isn't worth it. Unfortunately, to get the sunroof, you have to buy it.
-Don