I've been putting up with my '84 Sierra's lackluster alternator performance for a long time now. Unless driven very regularly, it would have dead batteries. Now it doesn't even really charge them when driven or run...the output starts out strong after starting (14.5 volts) but soon drops to 12.8 with next to no load (everything that can be turned on is turned off).
The battery connections look good at both ends, and neither battery is very old. The drive belt is tight, so I think the alternator is sick and dying. It is original to the truck as far as I know. I've been looking for a new one, and the consensus at various auto parts stores is that the alternator is rated for about ~75 amps maximum output on these trucks. This can't leave much left over for charging both batteries when you factor in headlights, radio, blower fan and all that stuff being turned on. It really seems like such a "small" alternator would lead a very hard life.
However, the clerk at Advance Auto Parts showed a number of beefier choices, going all the way up to a 140 amp rated unit. I'd tend to go for the larger alternator...the idea being that a larger unit would be under less stress and have more ability to take on heavy loads when they appear and while still charging the batteries.
What I'd like to know is if I'm on the right track here--if I should spend the extra money for the large alternator or choose something smaller (there are a few choices between the stock unit and the higher rated ones)? Also, would the larger unit be compatible with my truck (belt and mounting wise)?
Thanks in advance for any info, thoughts, whatever.
William