I am considering buying a BMW 3 series for my next vehicle. I have
never owned a 3 series, or any BMW vehicle, so I am doing a little bit
of research before I decide exactly what model and production year I
would like to buy. I have a few questions I would like ask this forum
to get me started.
1) What is the general opinion of the E36 series versus the E46
series? What are the pros and cons of each generation and overall
which is considered better?
2) The E46 received a facelift for the 2002 model year. What is the
general opinion of BMW enthusiasts, did the facelift improve the look
of the vehicle or was the original E46 look considered better?
3) What are considered the best model years for the E46? (I am most
interested in purchasing the sedan, or possibly the coupe, but
definitely not interested in the convertible or wagon)
4) Are there any significant differences between the four engines
installed in the E46 during it's production life (ie: old 2.5 l, 2.8
l, new 2.5 l, 3.0 l engines) as far as reliability and performance are
concerned ? (Other then the fact that the larger engines have more
power and torque).
Any advice would be most appreciated. If you can direct me to previous
threads that discuss my above questions, I would appreciate that also.
Owned both. E46 is far superior in build quality - the fit and finish
especially on the interior is a quantum leap better than the E36. Pro
for the E36 - it's cheaper (and breaks more) Con for the E46 - it costs
Beauty and the eye of the beholder. I don't think we can answer this for
you. Most people will state their preference is for whatever they own
at the time.
They are all good. Later ones tend to have more content (comfort
features). Of course you also will pay more for later model years.
[snip - snip]
I just bought my first BMW back at the end of May, first foreign as
well. It is a 2000 323I 4-door (E46 I believe) and had 117,000 US
miles. Now it has 130k miles on it. I get 29Mpg.
I love the car, I believe it has the 2.5L. It does not use oil,
according to the dealer records they did all oil services at the dealer
but exceeded the 15k a thousand or so.
The car is tight, love it and the only regret is not getting one sooner.
I am learning it is like any other car except like an aircraft it is
prudent to keep it maintained. I never heard a complaint about bad BMW
cars from owners or even previous owners.....
Hope this helps..
E46 was better build with better materials for those things other than
Eye of the beholder?
The latest car with the lowest miles, with lower miles being the tie
breaker. A car maintained above and beyond the recommended maintenance
interval would get a +. An automatic that's had a fluid change @ 50K miles
would get a double +.
Today's a bad day to ask me. I just picked up my 2002 325i after dropping
$700 on the 5th air pump and valve in 77000 miles. Fortunately the 1st 4
were under warranty. The car is tight and drives nice but the repairs are
getting rediculous. They also informed me that the transimission (manual)
is leaking(slightly) from two diferent seals. I've had more repairs done to
this car in 77000 miles than all the American-built cars I've owned over the
past 25 years. Nothing serious, just expensive.
It's actually two parts, an air pump and valve. The secondary air pump puts
fresh air into the mix for the first couple minutes of operation and then it
is supposed to quit as the car warms up. If it fails to shut off, it burns
out relatively quickly and you get a "check engine light". The car seems to
run fine, but I'm told that eventually you will burn out the catalytic
converters (mega-costly) due to an over rich running condition. I believe
the valve is a related component that opens or closes depending on the
situation. They changed them both each time the air pump failed.
fwiw, the secondary air pump and valve connect to the exhaust system, not the
intake induction system. The secondary air counters the extra-rich
engine-start condition from throwing a lot of unburnt fuel into the cat, which
would indeed, if not corrected, cause the cat to burn up prematurely. Once the
fuel/air mix at the cylinders has leaned out to the normal run state the
secondary air valve closes and the pump is turned off...
'00 s4 6spd
On Mon, 17 Dec 2007 06:08:33 -0800, jonfklein wrote:
I own an example of each vehicle and I agree with pretty much everything
others have said to this point.
For E36's, I'd look at the 96+ model years since they came with OBD II
diagnostics, electronic climate control, traction control (optional in
96, standard in 97), and a few cosmetic cleanups.
For E46's, you really can't go wrong with any of them except perhaps the
'01 model year, as they have had a relatively high share of issues with
the GM-sourced transmissions (BMW switched to a ZF unit in '02, IIRC) and
a few electrical gremlins (very rare for anything BMW, but there it is).
As long as the cars have been maintained and the owner has proof of that,
mileage is not as big a deal with these cars as it would be for some
other vehicles. In other words, don't be scared of the 100,000 mile mark
if it's a clean specimen and the price is right. FYI, auto transmissions
are known to fail in these cars at roughly 120K miles (very long story I
won't address here) and the manuals typically need clutches around the
same time. Be prepared for that and price the car accordingly.
Here are a few sites to continue your research, including my own:
http://forums.bimmerforums.com/ (emphasis on E36)
Your question is perfect for the tech support guy at The Roundel, the
magazine of the BMW Car Club of America.
You can reach the columnist, Mike Miller, at:
He will answer your message (very nice guy). He has issues with E36's
because that was BMW's first attempt at building a car down to a price point
and they screwed some things up as result. He owns an E46 coupe.
Every car maker ever makes cars 'down' to a price point and BMW are no
different. They were later than some of the same class introducing decent
rust protection - and on the E28 for example, made the bumpers out of
steel which rusted badly. Stainless would have been the choice if money
were no object. My E34 wore out the cloth upholstery very early on. Other
similar priced makes used cloth that lasts the life of the car. Just two
examples out of many.
*Could it be that "I do " is the longest sentence? *
Dave Plowman firstname.lastname@example.org London SW
Motorsforum.com is a website by car enthusiasts for car enthusiasts. It is not affiliated with any of the car or spare part manufacturers or car dealers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.