We all are familiar with the analogy about the flow of electricity
comparing with the flow of water: voltage being the water pressure in
the pipe, amperes the measurement of how much is passing through the
pipe, and ohms being the size of the orfice.
Using the water analogy, what is wattage?
I know my name is Einstein and all that, but hey. I don't know
On Mon, 21 Nov 2005 18:25:46 -0500, "Coasty"
wattage can be compared to capacity measured in gallons per minute.
This is the simplest (but not technically) the best analogy.
Hope this helps you understand.
P.S. By the name you can probably guess my occupation.
I think Coasty is probably as close to an answer as you can get. I am
not an expert--BUT--(you KNEW I was going to say that)--in electricity,
power is equal to amperes times the square of the resistance in the
circuit. In your example, the smaller that little orifice is, the
higher the resistance is. I think that the power in watts is just a
number. But in a circuit with resistance in it, the power has to be
dissapated somehow. With resistance heat is given off. In this
example, heat is also given off. But I don't think very much. First of
all, water doesn't compress very much. Second, there would not be much
friction going through that little orifice.
In other words, I don't think you could appreciably increase the water
flow above a certain rate, no matter how much pressure you had. This is
different than electricity. The current is directly proportional to the
Thoroughly confused? The electrons always know what they are doing --
and they will always react the same way to the same set of parameters.
So it is the way that we visually or verbally try to describe what is
happening that is a source of confusion.
The analogy between water and electricity in theory has some of the same
aspects in analogy only. The actual performance has similarities but the
affects are totally different.
It is like comparing apples to oranges, both grow on trees, growth based on
sun, water and soil conditions and that is where the similarities end. One
is a northern crop the other a southern crop, they taste different, they
have different skins, the interior of the fruit is structured different.
You can use comparative analyses to almost anything however, it is just
that. It has no real basis on theories or actual results. You can't power
a TV with water or drink a glass full of electricity, you can eat an apple
or an orange, so water is closer to apples and oranges that it is to
Sparks may be an electrician but he is not a hydrologist.
Since the original poster's question was pertaining to the actual
water analogy, I like the first response best, which I think speaks to
the actual 'brute force' (power) of the water coming out of the pipe,
and "how much of a machine it could drive if it were directed to driving
a turbine wheel."
The whole thread is a good illustration of how important it is to use
the proper size wire, etc for your application.
You're right, Jim. Same thing is true for air flowing through
tubing and an orifice or nozzle - when the flow reaches the speed of
sound in the fluid (liquid or air), the orifice chokes and maximum
flow rate (equivalent to wattage in the electrical world) has been
reached. I don't think there is an electrical analog to choking flow,
except that as the flow through a resistor increases withour limit the
I squared R heating would eventually burn out the resistor and stop
the flow, which is not the same thing as choking.
Motorsforum.com is a website by car enthusiasts for car enthusiasts. It is not affiliated with any of the car or spare part manufacturers or car dealers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.