Hmmmm...why do I get the impression I'm being toyed with here? ;)
One thing I do know: Particularly on my long-term cars (1980 Corolla SR5 and the GTS) it was easy to watch trends with my little notebook. The SR5 got 33 MPG in the end, and the GTS averages about 36. The 80 had a 1.8 Carbed engine and the GTS a 1.6 TC injected engine.
I still don't really have the tC dialed in yet. I don't drive it enough.
But, I drove the car in Vermont the first year I drove it, and I did notice an increase switching from Shell to the Ethanol fuel sold in Mass. About 2 MPG consistently.
However, I also had my Grand Voyager and the LHS at this time. The Gr Vger had a pushrod 3.3 liter and the LHS had an OHC 3.5 liter: the LHS also suffered (~2 MPG) on Vt gas, while the Vger was unaffected (27 MPG overall).
BTW, I use Shell and Gulf. Gulf is the 'lowest' brand I will put in my car, but it seems to work well. Now, ~15-20 years ago I was using Mobil in the GTS, and it developed pre-ignition. I ran two tanks of Techron and switched to Chevron and Amoco (when we still had them here) and the problem stopped.