Seeking advice on engine replacement

May 02, 2006 2 Replies

HI there I have a 1994 325is with 213Km on it and it is blowing white smoke out the exhaust. Various sources are telling me its best to get a new engine put in than to risk paying to have it torn down and examined for bad head gasket. I have a few questions:


1) Is there any way at all to determine whether I only need a new head gasket vs a new engine without paying several hundred dollars? for example, after its been sitting for 24 hours or more it blows a whole bunch of white smoke, then setlles down etc etc.. can symptoms pinpoint the cause without tearing the engine apart?


2) If I need a new engine, how can I avoid the pitfalls involved? It seems like everybody I call can get me a new engine with 117Km on it, exactly. I know that can't be the accurate mileage unless everybody is locating the same engine. I fear greatly that I'll get the engine replaced then have some problem , then fight with everybody for months trying to get blame accepted yada yada yada....


3) I live in Hamilton Ontario. Does anyone know a really knowledgeable, honest BMW guy who would help me out ( the key word there is 'honest'!)

Any advice would be greatly muchly appreciated.



Why would you want to replace the entire motor for want of a head gasket?

Yeah, pull the had off. Look at the head gasket and go "oh".

Either they're all trying to sell you the same engine (hahahaha) or else they're making s*it up.

Sorry; although I used to work there ages ago I don't know anybody there now. Belleville, sure, Landsdowne, past Kingston, yeah, but not the Burlington/Hamilton area. Where do you normally get it serviced?

Asking soebody in the trade might help. There's a guy who sells used tires out that way that knows everybody and has impressed me with hot hoenst he is. Try to find him (it's been a couple of years since I've talked to him)

For a start, is the coolant level going down?

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required