JD Powers Survey

There will always be those that can not afford a new car, that will be there to buy up all of the used cars.

mike hunt

John Ockerbloom wrote:

My buddy is a mechanic at a Toyota dealership, they're not as reliable as people think they are. They have just as many problems as other manufacturers. I don't subscribe to that mentality that most people believe jap scrap is more reliable than other cars. My wife's 97 ford contour has had not one lick of problem up until this weekend, I changed the water pump at 90,000k's. We have had it since 98. I just worked on a supra not more than two months ago which needed a new cam, worn lobes, warped head, so don't tell me that they're more reliable. Same goes for our Honda accord, replaced the cam at 130,000k's, again worn lobes. I quess they use cheap metal. I'm currrently trying a Hyundai sonota, and will never buy one of those again, nice looking car, but never again. All of these cars were a one owner brand new off the lot vehicles. I'm currently looking for a new car, and may go back to a European car, particular a German made car.

No car is going to be 100% problem free, but Toyotas and Hondas typically experience less non-routine problems than North American brands, especially if regular maintenance is kept up. But even with regular maintenance, North American brand cars tend to experience more non-routine problems, especially when they are at least 5 years old and/or the mileage gets up there. And this JD Power survey focused on (I think) 3-year old cars.

My '93 Accord has 223,000km (138,000 miles) and has been extremely reliable. My father and brother both have Corollas ('04 and '05) with about 30,000km (19,000 miles) each so far, and as expected, both have been reliable so far. But we have taken good care of our cars and kept up the regular maintenance.

Not all Japanese brands are reliable (especially Mazda, for example). But Toyota and Honda are typically more reliable than most others.

You've been lucky. I know a lot of Contour/Mystique owners who had lots of problems with them, including a few that had fires from under the hood.

Since it's a Supra, perhaps it was not well taken care of. The only common problem I am aware of (depending on the year) is the head gasket.

Since you appear to be in Canada (like me), I assume you are talking kilometers here? Anyway, that is rare for an Accord. But again, is it possible that it hasn't been well taken care of?

German cars are actually no more reliable than the others. Volkwagens are just plain junk, and apparently, Mercedes-Benz' quality has suffered since the DaimlerChrysler merger.

maintenance.

We had it since brand new, bought in 86, got rid of that scrap pile in 91 with a 130 k's on the clock. started to rust out pretty bad to. All routine maintenance done by me ( worked for honda dealership at the time ). The shop was well stocked with vehicles in for repairs and tsb's all the time. Same as the Toyo shop across the lot from them at that time, no different from a ford or gm or chrysler shop. Had just as many cars going through the doors as any one else. And to this day, at the auto mall here in the city i see the shops full of cars, Toyo's, Honda's, Gm's Ford's, and so on. I see no difference in reliability or the number of occurances in these cars than from any others.

That may be true, but I've had no problems when I owned a volks or Mercedes. But they were not brand new and were well into the hundreds of thousand of miles on the clocks, they were a 60,61, 65. My 190 my dad gave me as a grad present, had over 470,000 miles on the odometer, but I took the engine apart for restoration. I figured I refresh it, did not need it, but I wanted to bring this thing to brand new condition from a ground up restore. The hoses and lines needed replacing to get it like new again. To bad it burnt to the ground in a garage fire, it was a beauty, with ivory steering wheel and cherry wood dash, and wasn't insured. But it was a slug, barely moved, underpowered, but what a gorgeous looking car. Had no problems with it whatsoever.

No, MB has been junk for quite a while, no merger needed. German cars are not only junk, but ridiculously expensive to repair.

What gets me is VW puts out s*it, yet has a retardedly high resale value.

We also use block heaters up here in Canada on cold nights. I frequently hear 10+ year old Plymouth Acclaims with 300 000km+ tapping away from piston slap (when warm) no problem. Piston slap is usually more of an annoyance than anything major.

And how the body wouldn't.

Just curious, how do you know that ALL of those Hondas and Toyotas you saw in the shops were there for something other than regular maintenance (not counting TSB's and recalls)?

Perhaps your Accord was a rare lemon? I still see a handful of late 80s Accords running today. A friend of mine put close to 500,000km on an '86 Accord with very few non-routine problems. He ditched it in 2001 when the rust caught up with it, but the engine (carbureted) and auto tranny were still all original and good.

Perhaps you have seen no difference in reliability, but I have.

hehhe yes mazdas are now s**te ... can you blame them they are owned by ford

right .. my 1978 cordoba parked in the field wasnt parked because of body rot .... to much money for gas tho lol

I even hate getting involved in this, but... the fact is that most of my family (and friends) drives old cars, old American cars. And guess what, they run, and well. My daily is a 1980 Bronco with so many miles I've lost track. It's absolutely unstoppable. But at 10mpg, fuuuuck. My dad has a

I don't see many mid 80s Hondas on the road anymore. Where, did they go? Old American cars are everywhere. On the flip-side, all of ours are Fords. You can't say the same about Chev and Dodge. :)

Hey Bill, Not sure about newer VW, no experience. I've heard lots of complaints about MB, pre and post merger. One German vehicle that truly impresses me, though, is BMW. Granted, they are expensive in the US and Canada due to the Yuppie factor, but in Germany they are like Chevrolets (The impression I get from my German sister-in-law). The mechanical systems in BMW's, both 2 and 4 wheeled, seem to last nearly forever. I'm a die hard US vehicle(Ford) driver, but I have to give credit where credit is due. Granted, my personal experience with BMW is limited, but I've seen many with trouble free miles well into 6 digits. I also don't recall ever hearing a BMW owner complain about their car. BMW motorcycle owners seem to have nothing but praise for them. I've personally seen one go 12x,000 miles without any engine work whatsoever. Take that Honda, Yamaha, Kawasaki, and of course Harley Davidson. One Japanese car that really made an impression on me was Subaru.(1995 AWD Legacy) During a blizzard on the New York Thruway headed to Toronto from Cleveland, that car felt glued to the road (deep snow). When you pressed the pedal, it went. When you pressed the brake, it stopped. No wheel spin or brake lockup at all. I've never felt safer in severe winter conditions. I don't know about their reliability, but that experience would count if I ever considered an import. I like my Taurus and my Mark VII but I won't defend their weaknesses by tearing down other makes that I choose not to own. To each his own.

Depends on the model, and within BMW, you expect more (features/gizmos, ride comfort, and reliability) the higher in the series you go. The 3 series is considered by most other Bimmer owners as the "entry level" model, then folks work their way up with the packed dash 5 series, then gain some of the space back when they finally graduate to a 7 series. Sort of like going from the Cavalier to the Cadillac in GM terms. I knew a guy with a loaded 535 (I think it was a 2002 or 2003, that would spend his break and lunch time sitting in his, just start it up, run the A/C, and listen to tunes {or watch TV, I dunno, all I know is that you'd never find him in the lunchroom}). Gotta love the car to do that.

I attend old car show all over the country and I seldom see any old Japanese cars at show with the exception of an RX7 or a "Z" on occasion. Where are those old Japanese cars from twenty years ago if there are so durable?

mike hunt

BradandBrooks wrote:

Exactly. Who cares to answer this? Maybe they're hiding somewhere?

Brad

I was browsing the junkyard yesterday and they had quite a few Z's in there, also a 66 Chevy and a 60 Corvair.