been driving a Renault Clio

May 23, 2007 26 Replies

I've not driven one like this (thankfully) but I've heard a colleague of mine complaining about them on a new Astra he test drove. he said he kept indicating left when trying to turn the right indicator off and vice-versa not just annoying,bloody dangerous if you ask me.

My SEAT ibiza has proper latching indicator stalk but it also has the "flick" feature where if you flick it up or down it will indicate three times in that direction. Useful for changing lanes but bloody annoying and possibly dangerous if you flick it by accident as the only way to stop it before the 3 flashes is to indicate the other way!!

loony ( snipped-for-privacy@gmail.com) gurgled happily, sounding much like they were saying :

I still don't quite understand the point of self-cancelling indicators, other than to compensate for sheer indolence.

Or for that matter automatic windscreen wipers and lights.

I just wish rear fog lights were all turned off automatically when the ignition is turned off, as I hate being stuck behind some idiot that has them on from when it was foggy weeks ago.

[...]

Good idea in theory, but what about those vehicles that are used for frequent stop/starts?

It would be unreasonable to expect anyone to remember to turn them back on

20 or 30 times a day.

I agree with how annoying it is when they are misused. Perhaps some real traffic police and some high profile fines would help?

Chris

The message from "Andy" contains these words:

My Mundeo turns off the fogs whenever you turn the lights off - you have to intentionally switch them back on again the next time.

My Messerschmitt has a 3 way toggle switch for the indicators (similar in function to many motorbikes of course) ;-)

I think her XV750 might be self canceling (My R100RT isn't).

Pah, when I were a lad ... ;-)

All the best ..

T i m

Not a problem according to the manufacturers who actually do this - eg my BX does, and I reckong Guy's mondeo is a bit more mainstream.

If it's foggy enough that they're necessary, no it wouldn't be. It's very rare that it is that foggy, especially during the day and in towns which is when and where people doing that many stops would be driving.

cheers, clive

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required