YES, another servo problem. I've got the servo nailed as being the
culprit. My VOM reads 3 ohms in "park", 3 in hot, and 1485 in cold.
The motor will move (takes 5-10 secs for full travel) but heat/cold
control is erratic. Now, George Murphy at Performance Analysis Co.
(super friendly and helpful!) has a new/rebuilt servo that uses an
aluminum housing instead of that crappy plastic MB used. He's asking
595USD with a 1 year warranty. Germanstar
(http://germanstar.net/123h.htm ) has a similair one for 365USD (don't
know about a warranty). Does anyone have any knowledge on the
differences, if any, and quality of them? Also, George recommends
that the amp be replaced at the same time, just to be sure you've got
a good signal going to the servo.
Appreciate any help offered.
Thanks Tiger. Does MANTIS manufacture/rebuild these things using
aluminum, ala the other guys? MB's original product, quite frankly,
sucked. As I'm sure you know, the plastic housing was prone to
cracks, then coolant leaks, and corrosion of the delicate parts inside
the unit. Not to mention, they'd be happy to sell you a new OEM for
I have the Performance Analysis one in my car now for about a year.
The first one they sent, sprung a leak in about a week. George
quickly sent a replacement, which has worked perfectly. Not only is
their a full warranty for a year, after that they will fix it for
$100. Given the reliability of these, that sounds like a very good
idea. Also, the PA one has an aluminum lower housing. The plastic
one cracking and letting coolant leak is one of the primary failures.
Before you replace yours, try removing the upper portion of the
housing. I'm not sure from your post what ohms you are measuring, but
it sounds like they are from the feedback potentiometer, it may just
be dirty. This pot is at the top of the unit and is driven by the
position of the motor. It's part of the feedback system, the other
components being the thumbwheel setting pot, the in car temp sensor,
and the ambient temp sensor. That chain drives a voltage which moves
the motor. If that pot in the servo gets a dirty/bad spot, it will
cause erratic behavior. I watched mine with an ohm meter while I
drove the motor through it's full cycle. At one small point the pot
just went to an open condition. You can try spraying it with
electronic cleaner. It worked once on one of mine.
It's also a good idea to cycle the system at least every few weeks
from max heat to max cooling. That moves the pot through it's full
range and helps keep it from developing a bad spot.
firstname.lastname@example.org (Chet Hayes) wrote in message
Thanks for the post. I followed your instructions and "determined"
that the feedback pot WAS bad, sprayed it with cleaner --- no change.
Upon closer inspection, I discovered that this unit had been messed
with before. The silicone "witness blobs" on the screws were missing,
and the screws that held down the pot were partially mangled. The pot
also had a horrible solder job done to it. What had happened was that
the Joe that replaced it hadn't set it up properly, that is why I was
getting incorrect resistance readings. After a bit of fiddling around
with it, I had the exact readings to make this thing work. Still no
go. IMO, the gears/post that controls the coolant flow is pooched.
SOOOOOO, next step is going to be an after market servo. George at
PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS seems to have the best unit/warranty, bar none
($595). Germanstar.net has one for $365. Mr Auto Parts has one for
$261. The question is, are they all the same? I mean, that IS quite
a price spread...
email@example.com (AJ) wrote in message
I guess you'd have to ask the other vendors if they have an aluminum
lower housing, which the one from Perf Analysis does. The cracking of
the OEM plastic ones is a major failure mode. Also, if Perf Analysis
still offers lifetime repair for $100 after the one year warranty,
that alone is a deal closer for me.
Since the one you have appears to be shot, you can take it out and
fiddle with it some more. The motor is connected to terminals 1 and 5
on the forward most connector. The wires are brown and green on the
harness. If you take the servo out, you can run the motor by hooking
up a 9V household battery. Just reverse the polarity and it runs the
other way. When it stops, in one direction it's at max cool,
reversing till it stops in the other is max heat. Make sure you
disconnect the battery immeadiately when the motor stops, or else
you'll burn it out. In max cool, the water valve should be closed.
In full heat, it should be wide open. This process elimates the pot
and everything else, so you'll know for sure if the motor opens and
closes the valve.
I wouldn't bother trying to disassemble it beyond what you have done.
I took one all the way apart and it wasn't easy. It's hard to even
figure out how it all comes apart without destroying it and there is
little hope of ever getting it back together. How the hell PA
rebuilds these is beyond me!
BTW, if the servo is running back and forth in the car, I would not
bother replacing the AMP, as it should be fine.
In the PerformanceProducts.com web site there is a "New" Digital
replacement for the AC/Heater Servo.
It is $699 for the kit. It appears to be a lot smaller that the original.
Looks like about 5 pieces with a plug in wiring harness. They claim that it
installs in less that 2 hours and comes with a 5 year warranty. There is
supposed to be an online install procedure in PDF Format. Might want to take
a look at this.
Good to hear it worked out. I think all the ones available now are
rebuilt, as I remember seeing somewhere online that the original
manufacturer stopped making them. I guess they finally figured out
they were a piece of crap and weren't worth the trouble anymore.
Motorsforum.com is a website by car enthusiasts for car enthusiasts. It is not affiliated with any of the car or spare part manufacturers or car dealers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.