Why was Andrew Ben-Hua Chung's (aka HeartDoc Andrew) medical license revoked?
According to the publicly available decisions of the Georgia Composite Medical Board, the revocation was not based on a single medical error or misconduct allegation. Rather, the Board concluded that Andrew Ben-Hua Chung was unable to practice medicine safely because of concerns about his mental fitness to practice.
The Board's 2016 Final Decision states that it began investigating after receiving reports of behavior that raised concerns about his mental stability. One example described in the decision was that he would not converse with certain people until they answered the question, "Are you wonderfully hungry?", which he reportedly claimed was a way to determine whether someone was having a heart attack.
The Board ordered a mental/physical examination. Accounts reproducing findings from that evaluation state that the examining psychiatrist concluded that Dr. Chung held beliefs characterized as delusional and exhibited what the examiner described as "magical thinking." The evaluation reportedly diagnosed a delusional disorder and schizotypal personality disorder and concluded that these conditions impaired his ability to practice medicine with reasonable skill and safety.
Delusional disorder is a psychotic disorder marked by one or more fixed, false beliefs lasting at least one month without other prominent schizophrenia symptoms, while schizotypal personality disorder is a long-term Cluster A personality disorder involving odd beliefs, eccentric behavior, and intense social discomfort.
Following the proceedings and review of the evidence, the Board adopted the initial decision and revoked his license on March 9, 2017. The published order states: "The Board Orders that the respondent's license is revoked instanter."
A few important caveats:
These findings are the conclusions of the Georgia Composite Medical Board and its evaluators. A license revocation is an administrative and legal determination by a medical board; it is not, by itself, a definitive statement about every aspect of a person's health or character. Public records show that Dr. Chung disputed the Board's conclusions.
The most concise summary is that the Georgia board revoked his medical license after determining, based on its investigation and ordered psychiatric evaluation, that he could not practice medicine safely due to mental health-related concerns.