WHAT'S THE REAL TRUTH ABOUT REPLACING TRANNY FLUID?

Jul 08, 2005 10 Replies

I'm approaching 90,000 miles on my 1998 C230. I realize the transmission case is sealed and MB says no fluid drain or change is needed. However, I am still wondering what the advice among group members on this issue may be. I'm not a do it yourselfer...and rely on my mechanic with whom I have been doing business for mpre than 30 years. He'll do it if I ask...so, should fluid be drained and changed or not? thanks.



Sherm


It should most certainly be changed. My MB mechanics insists that the transmission lasts a lot longer with change every 60K miles (synthetic fluid). I got mine changed (99 E300TD) at 90K.

Raj

I have never changed the fluid in the transmission of my 190E and it is working properly now for more than 500000 kms.

Manfred

"gator_mech" schrieb im Newsbeitrag news:f3vze.62399$%Z2.33168@lakeread08...

Change it. Anybody but the dealer!

I think there is an aftermarket dipstick/filltube available through Baum Tools. I would change the fluid frequently.

I changed the tranny fluid the other day in my C230 (1998). No problem. Just drop the pan.. be careful as it can easily spill all over.. put in a new gasket..NO silicon etc. and bolt the pan back up. By the way jack the car to make it easy to do. Just to back up a little you need to run a small diameter plastic tube down the fill hole and note the level BEFORE you drain the tranny oil. When you fill... just fill up exactly the amount you drained. No more no less. This represents a 70% replacement and don't bother with the 30% that is still up in a part of the tranny that doesn't drain easily. when you change it again a little early say... 30,000 miles you will have a complete exchange of fresh oil.. The Germans were/are worried that the owner can't do that on their own.. Basically the MB is no different than my FD 250 Truck. Simple as that..

Larry

snipped-for-privacy@hotmail.com wrote:

I would probably have a proper drain plug put in the pan and add the dipstick if available, I would consider it cheap insurance.

thanks all...I'm going to have my mechanic do the job at my next sevice interval...

Sherm

I would say definetly yes. Have you had to add any to it? It also depends on what kind of driving you do. A lot of stop and go and ideling means that fluid has prob. been pretty warm a few times meaning it is or has been broken down in some way or another. We usually change (depending on driving conditions) at least every 25,000 mi or so but that is just the way we do it.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required