Re: quick poll - american cars

May 16, 2009 Last reply: 17 years ago 5 Replies


> >>


>>> Vic Smith wrote:
>>>
>>>> I have heard the apocryphal stories about Corollas going 200 miles
>>>> with no oil. Always by those who know squat about cars.
>>>> OTOH that Brit show - can't remember the name - beat the s*it out
>>>> of a Toy pickup and couldn't kill it, so I don't entirely discount
>>>> what you're saying.
>>> My mechanic works on a lot of different cars. The horror stories of
>>> short-lived vehicles always center around Ford and GM products that
>>> were run without oil or coolant because the owner never checked them,
>>> and the fluid levels were low for various reasons related to the >>> engine design.
>>>
>>> You ignore changing the oil or checking the coolant on a Toyota or
>>> Honda, and you may slightly shorten the life of the engine, but
>>> you're unlikely to have a catastrophic failure because oil
>>> consumption is minimal, the cooling system is unlikely to
>>> malfunction, and the engine block design has enough margin so that
>>> brief over-heating won't crack the block. It's very different on a
>>> vehicle that can't tolerate ignored maintenance because the engine
>>> burns oil, the water pump leaks coolant, and over-heating quickly
>>> cracks or warps the block.
>>
>> Again, you offer no specifics. Might as well be Joe Schmoe talking in
>> the lottery ticket line. And there are well-known instances of
>> sludging and head gasket failures of specific and common Toyota
>> engines, most likely caused by lax fluid maintenance causing exactly
>> the failures you're speaking of. Don't know about Honda offhand.
>> OTOH, I've abused plenty of GM cars to the point where the lifters
>> were clacking or the radiators were almost dry with no catastrophe.
>> If you're going to make sweeping generalizations without specifics you
>> just come across as an American-car-bashing-Toyota-lover.
>> No doubt you are, but that doesn't mean I don't like you.
>>
>> --Vic
>
> Ummmm... it's a rare American car with 50K or more miles where the
> lifters DON'T clack. I can always identify a GM product with a 2.8 V-6
> derivative by the unique blatty exhaust sound and clickety-clack of the > lifters.
>
> nate
>

Those could be the fuel injectors. Wife's 90 Beretta has 150k miles and the injectors clatter like a diesel. And yes, the exhaust note is horrific. Damn car's like a cockroach tho - nothing short of dynamite will kill it.


Ray


I know the sound well, from watching/hearing family members accelerate away from the house. I would think, "My car sounds like that!?" You'll never hear it behind the wheel though. And you won't hear it anywhere at cruise or idling. Only under load. As you say, it was the stock exhaust system design. My son put an aftermarket glass-pak type muffler on his 3.1 Corsica. After he converted it from the auto to a 5-speed Getrag. Totally different sound. But you'll never make a 3.1 sound like a high lift cam 352.

--Vic

I was always a big fan of the chambered pipe as used on the Vettes and Chevelles in the '60s as depicted here:

formatting link

What about wild women?

--scott

While the exhaust note is most prominent nearest the outlet, and directly behind it, the sound permeates the surrounding vicinity (to the chagrin of many).

Statistics clearly demonstrate that the highest prevalence of incidents with "cages" occur in residential areas, parking lots and other surface streets. Even with all the windows closed, the A/C at full song, the stereo blaring and screaming kids in the back, a driver is more likely to notice a large scooter with loud pipes in his or her proximity than otherwise.

Nah, although it may well be a concern for others (re: "stylers"), I've never been insecure enough to desire to impress total strangers by the vehicle I'm driving.

Only if it has something to reflect off of. Simple physics. In the city, it reflects, in the country, not.

I don't disagree with the accident statistics, but I do disagree that the noise helps except in rare cases.

Besides, it's the equivalent of running with the horn button taped down just to let people know you are there. Neither should be allowed by law.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required