Re: 2008 Smart commuter car gets 40 mpg and will selling in USA for $12k.

Jul 04, 2007 3 Replies


Michael Pardee wrote:


>
>> "Eeyore" wrote
>> > "Robert A. Cunn>> >
>> >>
>> >> Consumer Reports had a short article about the "Smart for Two" car
>> >> in their Dec '06 issue (not this same exact model).
>> >> They said it was the worst car they have ever tested.
>> >
>> > In what respect.
>> >
>> > It's the very best for parking.
>>
>>
>> The reliability seems truly substandard. I have occasionally lurked in
>> SMART forums and seen threads about seized alternators (lots and lots
>> of them), engine troubles, turbo troubles, doors jamming when hot
>> (actually a common problem with them apparently), transmission
>> problems.... For soft-top SMART models the motors in the Cabrio roof
>> are notoriously troublesome and repair is shockingly expensive. 50K
>> miles or 80K km is considered old in many circles, the way 250K miles
>> is considered for Toyotas and Hondas. Whether that is justified or just
>> the owners' expectations isn't clear.
>
> Considering it's a Mercedes product that's very disappointing.

Mercedes cars are consistently rated as unreliable in Consumer Reports for several years in a row. Pretty much the entire model line available in the USA.

I seem to remember them coming in pretty near last!

What's totally hilarious is when you bring up that stat with a Mercedes owner, and they go into a diatribe about precision, all those features are complicated, etc...

Then you point out that the just as complicated and loaded Lexus comes out at or near the top.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required