I have 45,000 miles on my 2400 Elantra GLS. I'm having the
transmission fluid changed on Wednesday and a new filter installed at
the dealer (I called AAMOCO and the manager kept on trying to insist
that a "Universal Oil" would work as well as SPIII.) I ended up
telling him about this group and its warnings about using the right
fluid and, and I decided not to go there (must be my female voice that
lessens the impact of what I say to some mechanics?)
Anyway, I'm taking the advice of this group on maintenance and I'm
going to have my radiator flushed somewhere. Are there any certain
"specs" for the radiator fluid or, can I get it done at Jiffy Lube
($60 vs who knows how much at the dealer). I'd appreciate your advice.
Also, I want to give a positive report to this group: I had a tune-up
done at my friendly, corner mechanic: spark plugs, air filter and oil
change all for $123.00. Not bad!
I'm also hearing a slight vibration noise from my rear wheels that
goes away when I step on the brakes. I have had the same brakes for
45,000 miles. Could it be the wear indicators?
Again, I trust this group and thank God you guys are out there! I read
PS I get about 22 miles to the gallon, but I commute back and forth to
work about 80 round trip miles a day back and forth through Boston
traffic. I have snow tires on my car. Does that mileage sound right?
I can actually read while I'm driving in the stop and go traffic, and
sometimes play Scrabble Blast on my cell phone while waiting to crawl.
I don't think the issue is that shops don't want to listen to you. I think
it's that the place you called doesn't want to spend the extra money it
costs to use the correct fluid. Good job not allowing them to service
There's nothing special about the coolant. Regular aluminum-safe ethylene
glycol will be fine. I haven't checked lately, but anything you can find
should fit that bill. It's easy to bleed your cooling system, so it'd be
hard for anyone to mess up too badly. Jiffy Lube should be fine for
The noise from the rear could be your brake pad wear indicators. The tend
to make a squealing sound whose frequency varies in proportion to vehicle
speed. I wouldn't be surprised if that were the noise.
22 MPG sounds a little low, but it's probably due to the conditions under
which you drive. Sitting in traffic kills fuel economy.
One thing I found with my own car is that the original rear brake pads
fit WAY too tight in the calipers, which caused them to stick, rub and
wear out prematurely. This seems to be a common problem, but I'm curious
if you've run into it. When I installed the replacement pads, I filed
the "ears" slightly to get a proper fit, which hopefully will prevent
I have an update to report! I bought my car back to the dealer and I
certainly get excellent service there, but, the price is out of this
world!! My rear brakes had about a month "left" on the pads. I have
46,000 miles on the car. they changed the pads ($200.00) They also did
a transmission "drain and fill" and they reported that my fluid was
black!! I should have had it changed at 30,000 miles, but, I was
searching for a job at that time and was lucky I could still make the
car payment and gasoline to go for interviews, never mind the luxury
of changing transmission fluid! They also cleaned my fuel filter and
reported it was full of carbon deposits. So: rear brakes, a drain and
fill, and fuel filter cleaning for the tune of $459.00. The bill
states the labor was $358.86. My question, I was there for an hour and
a half, does this mean they had two mechanics working on my car? My
front brakes have about 3-4 months left on them, which I'm happy
about: that means I will have gotten about 50,000 miles from my front
brakes and 46,000 on the rear.
I've never heard of "black" fluid. Something is wrong. I've seen it brown,
but that is under extreme circumstances and many more miles than you have.
He is either BSing you or there is some other problem. Do keep an eye on it
over the next few thousand miles to see if it darkens. I don't know about
the Elantra, bu t the Sonata, the 30,000 mile change is only under severe
conditions. I've driven cars for 200,000 miles and never changed fluid
and it was still nice and pink.
but, I was
OK, Now I know he was BSing you.
So: rear brakes, a drain and
This is why I don't go to dealers for normal service. Many shops (both
dealer and independent) charge a flat rate regardless of actual time. They
use a flat rate manual and the mechanics can make a forutne if th ey beat
the time and most do. There is too much incentive to cheat and shortcut.
Typical shop rates today are $60 to 980 per hour. Some much more in high
rent districts. The $100 in parts is very much in line.
That is pretty good really. Most fo the time the fronts go far quicker as
the front is heavier and takes most of hte braking force. Brake wear
depends strictly on use. I can drive 26 miles to work and hit the brakes
just three or four times, but where I used to live and work, I'd use them
over 100 times in 15 miles. Everyohe is different in ther drive patters and
driving habits so check them at 10,000 miles and depending on wear at that
time, perhpas more frequent.
Check that tranny fluid too. Repairs can be very expensive. If you can get
46000 miles from a set of brakes, I doubt you fall into severe driving and
the fluid should still look fresh, not black at that time.
A few thoughts - some of which may seem contradictory. For one - if you
fluid was black, then shame on you. Did you read your owner's manual?
Owning a car requires some attention. If you felt you could just get in and
drive then shame on you. That said - you did/do have every right to expect
that a new car (not just new to you), should meet certain expectations. If
it's a new car, even if it's past the "recommeded" intervals in some cases
(such as tranny fluid), one should not expect to see catastrophic
conditions. At 46K, I would not expect to see "black" fluid. I'd be
throwing that right back at the dealer. Obviously, something is wrong with
the tranny and having the fluid changed at 30K would have done nothing more
than to (possibly) mask the problem. But... you own the car. It remains
your responsibility to keep an eye on things. If you really think you can
just drive a car and all is well, then I consider you to be...well, let's
just say... naive.
You clearly have a tranny problem if ithe dignosis is correct. I'd hold the
selling dealer accoutable if appropriate. If all this dealer did was change
"black" fluid, then I'd have a whole bunch of other concerns. Transmission
fluid does not become black without other problems - all, repeat... ALL of
which require attention. This smells bad.
At once, tough and no-so-tough. Your financial problems are not the issues
of the dealership. If you can't afford the mainenance for your car then you
should expect to pay the price on the back end - if there is a legitimate
price to pay. But - like I said, these are not magic intervals and
something is not smelling right about your story. Either there is more that
you are not telling, or you got taken badly. Either option is equally
probable. There is no such thing as "Luxury" when it comes to maintaining
your car. Either you maintain it or you pay the cost of repairs for not
maintaining it. Some times those costs are negligible to nill for short
term stretches, and sometimes those costs are huge. Regardless - they are
your decisions, and you costs.
Bull. Nothing more to say other than "BULL".
Billing is based on book rate. There is a book rate dictated by the
manufacturer for what any given job should be worth, in terms of repair
time. If the mechanic can do it in less time, more power to him. The job
is worth $N and $T (time), and if he can do it in less time, then he's
simply more efficient. You're paying for the job - not for the mechanic's
Your front to rear time intervals are way out of whack. Front brakes wear
about 2:1 against rear brakes - worst case. In other words, you rear brakes
will go far longer than you front brakes if everything is correct. Think
about this - which way does your car dive when you apply the brakes? Does
it nose dive or does it set back on the rear springs? It nose dives! 80%
of your braking is done by the front brakes. They will wear faster than
I want to steer you to looking at your dealer in a favorable light, in that
their rates have a reasoning behind them. They will always be more
expensive than an independent shop and they will never match up to book
rate, but a good dealer (despite these discrepancies) is still a good bet
for the casual car driver/owner. At the same time, there are dealers out
there that really screw people. I'm just trying to throw my two cents in so
that you'll see where you are getting screwed and encourage you to continue
to seek out a good dealer. They're out there. You have to carry your end
of the bargain as the car owner, but having done that you should be able to
expect fair and reasonable service from the dealer.
Why not try the guy that did the tuneup? I'd trust him over some Jiffy Lube
Could be, that is pushing the brake limits in miles. While you have the car
in for the radiator flush, get him to check the brakes. If you found a
good, relialbe, independent mechanic, stick with him and he is less likely
to jack the bill on you. Heck, ask him about the transmission change also.
Yeah, the heavy traffic is a killer on mileage. When you are sitting still
you are getting 0 MPG. If you live anywhere near Northbridge, get Bill's
Radiator to do the flush for you.
Motorsforum.com is a website by car enthusiasts for car enthusiasts. It is not affiliated with any of the car or spare part manufacturers or car dealers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.