4 seater pick up - opinions

Feb 11, 2008 12 Replies

Right then, we wanted a new Multipla but Fiat dealers are frankly putting me off buying from them so I am looking at other alternatives and thinking about a pick up with 2 rows of seats (crew cab?).



We really just need something that will carry 3 people, a dog and a fair bit of gear. Preferably it will drive more like a car than a 4x4 (had an Isuzu Trooper, hated it), return a reasonable MPG, be mechanically reliable and manual (which seems to rule out a Hilux Surf)



I was only after a new car because it was going to be a Fiat so if I go down this other route I am not too bothered about age.



Any input appreciated.


R D S ("R D S" ) gurgled happily, sounding much like they were saying:

Almost any "full size" estate car, surely?

And you're seriously considering a crewcab 4x4 pickup?

And watch the fuel gauge fall at motorway speeds!

If you want something that handles like a car, look at estate cars.

Accompanied by the sound of a chisel on slate R D S, managed to produce the following words of wisdom

If you hated the Trooper, you'll hate every pick up crewcab there is.

As others have said get a largish estate. Mondeo Mk3 Estates are huge inside and the diseasel ones are mega-cheap to run (and don't have the rear axle bush issues the saloons / hatches can have).

If I didn't tow trailers or go off road, I'd have one instead of the Range Rover.

Face it, at the moment this

formatting link
would be a suitable replacement for the Range Rover :-)

cheers, clive

Well an Astra was MUCH too small, Multipla with rear seats out is OK.

Just thought i'd ask, i've read that 2 litre ish diesels will give almost

40mpg.

At a constant 50mph.& glacial acceleration, 1970s NVH levels & handling that makes one fondly remember the Morris Marina.

Astra certainly isn't "full size". Think mondeo, passat, c5, 406, v70, etc.

cheers, clive

I've had a guy lose one at what seemed like a reasonable speed in front of me. No diesel etc on the road, it just went. I was driving a Polo and catching him through an island, and the back end just started coming round. It shook him up a bit as he demoslished the road sign sideways, and came to rest facing me. I was very glad I'd eased off a bit- something didn't feel right.

R D S ("R D S" ) gurgled happily, sounding much like they were saying:

So look at Mondeo-size.

Oooh, ya bastard.

I've been promised it'll be back on the road in a couple of weeks. As long as its working by the middle of April I'm happy.

You really aren't going to like a pick up if you didn't get on with a 4x4. I'd say estate car or any MPV...

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required