1996 S500 (w140) timing chain

Hi all,

When driving abroad (I'm from UK) last Thursday, my car (S500 LWB from

1996, W140) broke down seconds after taking off from a parking lot. The engine just seemed to lock up. Didn't crank when trying to restart, all warning lights on.

The vehicle got towed away to a local Merc garage. Called me to say that the timing chain had broken and the engine locked up as a result. Quoted me over 33,000 euros (!) to fix by putting a new engine in.

Question: while I understand that valves could have been damaged as a result of the timing chain breaking, is it likely that this has put the entire engine beyond repair - especially since I had only just taken off again?

33K euro is clearly well beyond the value of this vehicle. Are there any other options I should consider or do I write the vehicle off?

Also, I thought this was not supposed to happen with these vehicles? I asked an engineer about a year ago whether or not I had to have the timing chain replaced (then 93K miles, now 100K exactly), he said no, they did never need replacing...

Guido

Reply to
Guido
Loading thread data ...

Your engineer is a little mistaken.

The chains stretch over time. Then the tensioner can't adjust for the stretch. Then the chain starts flopping and breaks the plastic guides. Usually the first rail to break is on the left side, inboard at the bottom of the head. Then there is so much slop that the chain jumps teeth, usually on the left head 1st.

Average life span is 100K miles.

Reply to
Karl

Three choices: repair this engine - new / rebuilt cylinder heads, cams etc. or buy a used engine from a salvage yard that was in a wrecked car and have its timing chain replaced before that motor is installed in your car. A 420 V-8 might also fit (check before proceeding) and that would enlarge the choices of available used motors.

If you really want to keep the car for a long time a M-B or independent factory rebuilt motor is a third, more expensive alternative. see

formatting link
The 33,000 euro shop should have given you these choices but as it didn't, that shop is probably not the place to use for this repair.

Reply to
T.G. Lambach

Thirty-three *thousand*!?! My goodness, you could buy a newer car for that much. Thirty-three *hundred* sounds high for the top end of this engine (remove & replace valves both heads). I would get another estimate, this mechanic clearly has a boat.

Reply to
me

He was wrong, it's one of the major deaths of Mercedes engines.

Get a good used engine. CHange the timing chain, oil pump chain and oil pump. Have the heads done. Good as new. for I'd gues about 4K.

Reply to
Richard Sexton

Reply to
jimcollins123

Richard Sexton wrote: > He was wrong, it's one of the major deaths of Mercedes engines.

Oh, damn - if he would even have hinted at the possibility of the bloody thing breaking, I would not have hesitated to get it replaced.

I hope this is not a naive question, but would it not be cheaper to replace valves and cylinder heads in my current engine?

G.

Reply to
Guido

The 8 cylinder models have it worse but you shuold still have the stretch measured. With regular frequent oil changes the chain should last longer but they all need to be checked and replaced at some point. 68K isn't quite worth worrying about yet though.

Reply to
Richard Sexton

Yeah no kidding. He didn't do you any favours.

These are interference engines so the pistons invariably contacted the valves meaning new pistons and rings - and you relaly can't bore out these engines as they're made with silicon impregneated aluminum; when the aluminum is ecthed away only the silicon remains on the cylinder walls.

If all 8 of the pistons are clean then you could get away with it, they should be able to use a boroscope to check, but don't count on being able to reuse them. THe other problem is if the piston mashed the valve around and bits scarred the engine bore then it's, sadly, scrap now I"m afraid.

Reply to
Richard Sexton

Reply to
mjanusz

IS there some simple way to check the timing chains for stretch or do you have to do a lot of disassembly to do an inspection ?

Reply to
GM

Turn the right cam with a wrench clockwise so the chain tensioner fully seats and hold it there. Now try to lift the chain up over the teeth of the right cam, on the left side of the gear. If you can move it a tooth, it is time to change it.

Reply to
Karl

"Engineered like no other car in the world!"

Reply to
Rob

MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.