9000 Transmission Decision

So here's the problem...

At the beginning of the year I bought a 1998 9000 CSE 2.3T "Anniversary". Very nice condition, 96000 miles.

Soon afterwards she developed a minor bump just before coming to a stop. So off to my Saab dealer who diagnosed an "internal fault", took the transmission out and sent it off for a rebuild. Some time, and quite some money later the car came back - exactly the same as before - no change. I did post a query here about what to do next then and received very helpful replies. The other possible causes seem to have been eliminated so to cut a long story short I think I have four options now.

  1. To have the box rebuilt again (garage to pay) at a ZF approved workshop this time! (Original rebuild cost 1400 pounds after refitting). No extra cost to me.

  1. The garage to put a replacement "known to be good, low mileage" unit (again at their cost) - this seems the least satisfactory since it could develop a fault at any time and I would be the 1400 pounds down with no guarantee. No extra cost to me.

  2. To put in a re-manufactured unit from Saab/ZF at around 2500 pounds plus fitting (minus the original 1400 paid to the garage) This figure was an estimate from the dealer.

  1. To import a NEW transmission from thesaabsite.com (there are no longer stocks in the UK or in Germany of the 4hp-18). Link here -

formatting link
At a cost of 1760 US (around 1500 pounds by the time delivery to the UK and tax has been added). This seems quite cheap really.

Option 4 seems the most logical as I want to keep the car for as long as I can, plus I have an insurance policy that will be paying 60 per cent of the bill. Surely a brand new box is the best option anyway - right or wrong?

So, if I go with option 4, is there anything that I should check and double check before the unit starts its voyage to Europe?

Thank you for your time.

P. (remove xs to email)

Reply to
Piers
Loading thread data ...

Damned difficult call - but I would actually go with option one.

This is because a ZF approved shop *should* be able to properly diagnose the transmission before repair to find out why *exactly* the transmission is making the bump. I would insist that the whole car be sent to the approved ZF shop for a good once over to exclude all other systems interacting with the transmission before dismantling.

Reply to
Dexter J

Reply to
Edward Hayes

As you say - tricky call.

I would also go for option one - not least since the garage ( and its agent ) failed to diagnose the fault.

You also have nothing to lose by following this route. A ZF approved shop ought to be able to rebuild decent box from yours ( make it clear that any questionable bearings etc aren't re-used ) - it's not like it's old and compares favourably to option 3.

Graham

Reply to
Pooh Bear

MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.