We just became owners of a 2001 outback ltd with a 2.5L 4cyl engine and automatic transmission. The car has somewhat high milage at 75000. My wife is concerned about some engine noise that is audible from inside the car, even when the engine is warmed up. At first I chalked this up to the piston-slap problem, but she keeps on hammering me with this issue, making me more paranoid.
Could there be some other cause of the noise in the engine, like maybe valve lash or something? It kinda sounds like it could be valve lash to me but I don't know enough about these engines to make a guess. It's kind of a tapping sound, and it does vary with RPM. However the noise is fairly slight and certainly can't be heard with the radio turned on. It's most noticeable at low RPMs, like when taking off at a green light.