Speedometer Transmission Gear Failure 99 Beetle

Oct 20, 2005 4 Replies

My daughter has a 99 New Beetle. This car has been a piece of poo-poo since day 1.



She has had repeated problems with the transmission not shifting properly and has had to have the "Speed sensor" and all sort of work down on the tranny to resolve this problem.



Recently she was stopped at a light and a drunk driver plowed into the rear of her, pushing her 5 feet out into the intersection. the speedo and odometer were working fine before this, and the check engine light wasn't on. (This is in Massachusetts, a "no fault" insurance state.)



The next day she noticed that the speedo and odometer weren't working and the check engine light had come on.



The insurance adjuster said that the "check engine light and speedo" weren't accident related. I said they were. So I went to the VW dealer and they diagnosed the problems. They said I have a sheared gear in the transmission, it will cost $1000 dollars to fix, and they "don't know" if it is accident related on not.



Does it feel like I am getting the saft here?



Anyone have any advice on how to proceed? I am thinking of going directly to the drunk drivers insurance company, but I am annoyed that everyone is just shrugging the shoulders and expecting me to just say "oh well, my bad luck".



Ideas?


The speedo drive gear is made of a plastic like material. Could the sudden shock forced onto the driveline cause the gear to fail? Maybe, maybe not. I would "push" the issue with your insurance company aggressively. Another possibility is, if you purchased the car new then it's covered by VW's

10year/100,000mile powertrain warranty.

Thanks, I'm going to.

You surprised me with the 10 year/100K miles powertrain warranty thing..

I bought this in 99 and I thought it was 3 years 36K miles.

By new, you got to be the first owner.

Hmm... I bought it with 4K miles on it... used.

I never knew the new ones had that warranty.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required