Well, the 4-door had the Sports Package that came with 225/55x15s and the rag top had 205/60x15s. The M3 rims that I have carry 225/45x17s. The overall diameter of these is 24.74, 24.69, and 24.97, respectively. Regardless of what the tires sizes were at one time, both cars ran with the M3 wheels, and this is the mileage benchmark that I am using.
No, they both have the same size now, but different mileage numbers.
I was thinking the same thing, the CD difference ought not be the explanation for a 10% variance in fuel mileage on two otherwise similar cars.