Here is our experience with Subaru's
Wife drives a 2000 Outback wagon 4-cyl automatic trans. awd (made in Indiana). It has almost 60,000 miles -- no problems since day 1 other than a single bad spark plug at around 39,000 miles. Car has had no other repairs other than normal maintenance.
Our son drives a 1995 Legacy wagon 4 cyl- automatic trans. awd (made in Japan). It has over 130,000 miles -- did have some problems with lights for heater control panel and radio display, but engine and trasmission totally without problems. I replaced front CV joints around 125,000 miles before I gave the car to my son.
I currently am driving a 1992 Subaru SVX 6-cyl (230 hp) automatic trans. (made in Japan). Bought it used last summer with 135,000 miles. It is a fun car and engine and transmission are great. I have replaced wheel bearings and CV's joints, but previous owner was young guy who put on almost 60,000 miles in a little over two years, so I think the car was driven hard.
Also owned an 85 Subaru GL wagon 4-cyl FWD manual trans. that I put over 100,000 miles on over 9 years with no real problems other than the clutch needed to be replaced twice.
I drove the 95 Legacy wagon for first 125,000 miles and it handled slighty better than my wife's Outback (even with new Dunlop performance tires on the Outback). The Outback has higher ground clearance compared to Legacy and thus I would definitely recommend a Legacy over an Outback to anyone who enjoys taking the twisties at higher speeds.
I am sold on Subaru's -- like any car they will need some repairs, but for the money, you can't match the security of AWD, safety, good fuel economy (compared to other 4-wheel drive or all-wheel-drive vehicles), reliability (check Consumer Reports -- almost all Subaru's built in the last 5 to 10 years are on their lists of recommended used cars) and they feel solid and are fun to drive.
An Indiana Subie fan.