Hi all, I'm new to this group and would appreciate your opinions on the
Back in 1997 I had a 2 litre Xantia estate which I thought was a superb
car. Unfortunately, when I quit my job the company insisted on me
returning it to them :-( Nine years on and I've just pensioned off a 7
Series Beemer - bl00dy awful thing - and am seriously thinking about
another Xantia; maybe 97 - 2000 vintage and preferably an estate.
So, here come the questions:
1. Which is the best engine to opt for taking into account power,
smoothness and economy - I drive about 25000 miles a year mostly on
motorways. I will consider both diesel and petrol engines.
2. What are the differences between the various models (SX/LX/etc) and
are there any serious omissions from any of them?
3. What should I look out for when going to view a car? Are there any
common faults to be aware of?
4. If you were in the market for a used car right now would you buy a
Your thoughts would be much appreciated :-)
I have it in a ZX, which is a smaller car than the Xantia, but the 1.9
non-turbo diesel is economical, smooth, and reliable; very easy to drive
around town or in country lanes, but you won't shake off the cops if you
need a quick getaway.
I shall certainly consider a Xantia next time I'm buying, if I have enough
The 1.9 non turbo was mindblowingly, unbearably slow in the Xantia. And
expensive, considering the total abscense of performance. Utterly,
utterly awful. I thought it was too slow to live with, and I drive a
siani (I also had the 1.9d and liked it in a ZX beforehand, though)
My 1.9D got a little more oomph after I had it serviced properly, but I
agree that the acceleration at motorway speeds isn't going to break any
records. For gentle cruising, it works very well indeed in the ZX - and
if you have the nerve to keep your speed up on country roads then the
handling of the car can see off some much 'faster' (and more expensive)
vehicles. The Xantia is heavier though, so the turbo diesel would
probably be worth considering.
Whiskers ( firstname.lastname@example.org) gurgled happily, sounding much like
they were saying :
A few years ago, my CX was in dock for a week or so for a head gasket and a
few other bits.
I got one of the 1.9D ZX loaners. It was flat at about 80mph when I picked
it up. It was also VERY smokey...
A thousand miles in a week later, and not only didn't it smoke, but I'd
seen north of 100mph out of it...
The first time I floored the accelerator on mine (overtaking a string of
lorries going up a steep hill on a dual carriageway - I was in 3rd gear) I
left a shocking smoke-screen. Almost as bad as some of the lorries.
I haven't had that much out of mine, but I will admit to more than 90 if
no-one official is listening; that didn't red-line the rev counter.
It's getting hard to find any road in the UK that isn't at least
apparently under the watchfull eye of a speed-camera. I have a strong
aversion to 'getting a ticket'.
I had a 1.9D BX a few years ago and whilst not brilliantly fast was
certainly adequate for my needs and good for 90+. The 1.9 TD Xantia didn't
seem to be all that much faster and the economy was definitely worse, not by
much 44 instead of 47 overall.
SteveG (_@_._) gurgled happily, sounding much like they were saying :
Diesel. 1.9TD, 2.1TD or HDi, according to what you can find.
1.9's easiest to maintain, other two are smoother/faster.
v6 petrol is *gorgeous*, but thirsty and a maintenance nightmare.
VSX & Exclusive have Hydractive suspension - lovely, but more hassle to
maintain - SX is everywhere, LX is pikey sales rep. Special editions are
numerous and vary. Aircon should be damn near ubiquitous except on
pikeyspec. Leather electric seats VERY worth going for, because they're a
different - and better - shape of seat.
Where to start... Even the newest Xants are getting into late middle age
I'd probably look at a C5, to be honest.
Actually, no, I'd look at an XM - or even a CX - but I'm wierd like that.
Thanks for the couple of comments so far - points have been taken on
I'm currently looking at a 1997 diesel VSX estate which has had a Van
Aaken smart box fitted. I've looked at their web site (www.vanaaken.com)
but it just gives typical marketing/sales bumf. Anyone have an opinion
on this modification?
I have a 90hp Hdi in a '99 Xant - what an excellent car! I'd have probably
gone for the 110hp version knowing what I know now but the 90hp is actually
fine for all legal speeds and upto 115mph on the autobahn ... ;-)
dunno - I got a bog std Xant (SX?) it's got aircon and a rear wiper which
were top of my list!
dunno - non that i've come across at 140000miles ... oh, the ABS packed up
recently but it was just a wheel sensor (as prediceted here and by the chap
in the garage ...)
yes - but I'd want a 110hp common rail diesel with the active anti-roll
suspension - which was never an option apparently ... so I'd probably go for
a diesel V70 as they dont roll as much as the Xant and handle a bit better
Hi again folks. Firstly, a huge thanks for all the comments and
suggestions - much appreciated. I've shelled out some of the hard earned
on the estate I mentioned the other day. Very pleased with it so far and
will become intimately acquainted with it at the weekend replacing the
Perhaps someone can clarify something for me here: just how many spheres
are there at the back of a VSX estate with hydractive suspension - is it
3 or 4?
This newsgroup may not be as busy as others I frequent but the
information is equally as good :-)
It's post-facelift with anti-sink ... so 4 it is. The previous owner
tells me the hydractive sphere was changed last year so I may pass on
that one this weekend.
Leads me to the next question: how do I tell which one is the anti-sink
and which is the hydractive? Are they obviously different?
Antisink is the one that has a pipe bolted to it. If its in the car, the
antisink sphere is right next to the height corrector and faces front-rear.
Hydractive is up high, next to an electrical connector, facing left-right.
Eduardo K. | Darwin pone las reglas.
http://www.carfun.cl | Murphy, la oportunidad.
Motorsforum.com is a website by car enthusiasts for car enthusiasts. It is not affiliated with any of the car or spare part manufacturers or car dealers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.