Greetings,
I posted a note on this before and got some good suggestions. I have some more information now an would like some more opinions.
Here is the background:
Truck has about 82,000 on it. Use it mostly empty, but occasionally drag about a 10K boat. Florida is mostly flat and the truck has not had a problem towing the boat in overdrive at about any speed I want, although, when I do tow, I normally keep it under 65 and usually at 55-60. At 70MPH, the truck turns about 1850 RPM or so in overdrive.
A few months ago, I noticed that the truck would seem to get stuck in first gear. Eventually, it would shift to second if I revved it high enough and then seemed to act normally through the other gears. This symptom would come and go.
Then, about a month ago, it would seem to get stuck in first gear more often.
Now, it seems to start out in second gear and then shift through the other gears just fine and very rarely does it get stuck in first.
I flushed the tranny and changed the fluids. The pan did have some metal particles in it and the oil was kind of dark, not black, but kind of a reddish brown. It did not smell burnt and my tranny temp gauge rarely moves. However, occasionally, and only lately does the tranny temp gauge get into the middle of the range if I am towing in stop and go traffic.
I have been given advice to either:
1) Change the tranny 2) Have it rebuilt 3) Change the solenoids or governor componentsThe check engine light has never come on, but the guy that flushed the tranny did say there was a 'code' that appeared but would not tell me what it was. I never did trust tranny shops as they always seem to give vague answers or refuse to discuss price. They seem to treat issues as some sort of black art or something. I do not have a code reader but should probably invest in one.
I am fairly handy and more then capable of swapping a tranny out or changing some simple components, but I would not tackle a tranny rebuild myself.
The up side of all this, is that when the tranny was working fine, I was averaging about 16 MPG. Now that it starts off in second, I am getting close to 19 and the rest of the truck is fine. So, although I need to get this fixed, there is no real sense of urgency.
Anyway, any advice or guidance would be appreciated.
Thanks,
Clint ====