Just wondering if anyone knows if the filters at carquest and UAP / NAPA
are Wix or what in Canada?
I'm trying to avoid FRAM filters all togather.
What I want is a WIX filter... i've bought them before but can't recall
where. Internet states Carquest and NAPA are WIX, but that may only be
in the USA. Hard to find a WIX branded filter here for some reason.
Thanks for the help
If you use Motorcraft filters at the recommended interval, you can always
tell Ford that you used their recommended filter...
You might be able to save nearly one dollar or so by puchasing an
I don't give a rats ass what you decide... giving it some thought would be a
I know I could save money purchasing aftermarket filters... Somehow - saving
75 cents or so just doesn't seem to be cost effective.
But what the fuck do I know?
I don't know what you know, but the Motorcraft filters and the Napa
Gold filters are likely very close to the same price, depending how
and where you buy them - and at one time they WERE identical. Not sure
about right now - and that's in Canada - no idea if it is different
in the states. I believe both were/are made by Dana Corporation.
Purolator has also made motorcraft filters in the past - and MAY still
be manufacturing some or all of them in certain markets?
At any rate, either a Dana/Wix or Purolator built filter are
reasonable filters, and as Jim says, the dealer filter is NOT
overpriced and you know Ford will be happy with your choice in case of
Interesting side note....
"Back in the day" - this being the 1980's, most of Fords engine line up used
the FL1-A oil filter. Back then, IIRC, the FL1-A cost about $7.95 CAD...
making it a pretty spendy filter for the day (but still my choice for my own
vehicles). At the same time, the also supplied the CFL-1... a "consumer
grade" (I guess you'd call it) oil filter that sold for about a buck99...
competing with most department store brands at the time. Cutting the two
filters open showed the vast differences and the desirability of the more
Now.. at that time, any engine repairs that required the oil to be changed,
the oil change was a cost that the customer was supposed to pay (being a
"maintenance OP"). When a warranty repair was made with a resulting oil
change, an FL1-A filter had to be installed.... Using a CFL-1 would result
in a warranty claim being kicked back.
Oil filters are not all create equal.... not even if they come out of the
same building/assembly line/whatever. Choose carefully... choose wisely...
Actually, the Villager was a joint venture between Ford and Nissan - with
the Villager being a nearly cloned Quest...
Not sure if you have seen this
http://minimopar.knizefamily.net/oilfilterstudy.html It's been a few years
since I last read it closely and it has moved a few times and changed a few
times... But I think it is a pretty fair comparison of filter features and
things to watch for...
Sidebar.... many years ago, we compared two couches... (here in canada we
call them chesterfields). One was on sale at the Brick Warehouse for about
$299. It featured a frame made of softwood, cheap springs and padding and
inferior covering material. We looked at a similar sofa at a privately owned
furniture store. This one was nearly $1200. Top quality coverings, top
quality springs and padding and a frame made of hardwood. My last Brick
warehouse cocuh had lasted less than two years... My $1200 couch was, after
20 years of faithful service given to friends of the family.... Approaching
30 years of age, it still looks pretty much like the day we bought it.
Now.... somebody reading this might assume that I am suggesting the
expensive couch is going to be the best choice. NO!!!!! I am suggesting that
if you are going to buy something - cost is only one of many
considerations.... ergo... we do our best to perform a cost/benefit analysis
and pray like hell we made the right choice.
High price is no assurance that we WILL get top quality... but low price is
usually a good indicator that we WONT get top quality.
I guess I was just trying to find an aftermarket filter that i could get
one for the honda accord and my two fords (car and truck). maybe ford
makes one that is the same as the honda but i doubt it... guess i could
go to the honda dealer too for filters.
Who makes Honda filters?
Motorsforum.com is a website by car enthusiasts for car enthusiasts. It is not affiliated with any of the car or spare part manufacturers or car dealers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.