Consumer Reports 2007 Auto Survey

Apr 16, 2007 3 Replies

I just completed my 2007 Consumer Reports Subscriber Survey. I though people who don't participate might like to see the sort of questions that are used to create the results reported in the magazine..


*********************** If you had any problems with your car in the past 12 months that you considered SERIOUS because of cost, failure, safety or downtime, select the appropriate box(es) for each car. INCLUDE problems covered by warranty. DO NOT INCLUDE: 1) problems resulting from accident damage; 2) recalls; or 3) replacement of normal maintenance items (brake pads, batteries) unless they were replaced much sooner or more often than expected.

Considering all factors (price, performance, reliability, comfort, enjoyment, etc.), would you get this car if you had it to do all over again?



How satisfied are you with this vehicle with respect to each of the following factors?



Did this vehicle get any MAINTENANCE (e.g., oil change/lube/tire rotation) or REPAIRS in the past 12 months?



Was any work done on this vehicle in the past 12 months (excluding tire replacement or accident damage) covered by a warranty or by a recall notice? Select ALL that apply.



Which, if any, of the following performed the maintenance and repairs? Select ALL that apply.



New car dealer (which sells your make of car) Independent local service station Repair or service chain such as Jiffy-Lube, Midas Other



How satisfied were you with the service for each of the following?



New car dealer (which sells your make of car) Independent local service station Repair or service chain such as Jiffy-Lube, Midas Other


***********************

If your cars actually had a problem (and neither of mine did), you get additional question about the area affected, but it all depends on what the respondent considers significant and they don't collect cost data. Yet from this limited questionnaire, that is only sent to Consumer Reports subscribers, CR generates "data" that million use to make buying decisions.



Ed


I consider the information generated by Consumer Reports more reliable than a news poll of 1200 people deciding who the leading candidates are in each party or 50 people interviewed after voting to decide which way that polling place has voted. Consumer Reports has never let me down, but some of these other pollers sure have!

Who best able to determine whether they would be willing to buy that car again? All of those questions are subjective indeed but it ultimately comes down to the impression that vehicle made on the owner. Remember that the data is viewed in a cumulative fashion, a few stupid responses will not skew the results for the vehicle's overall reliability rating.

If you are suspicious of the questionaire's methods how do you explain the good ratings that some Ford and GM vehicles received when the overall impression of those brands has been in the dumps for the past many years? Everyone "knows" Japanese cars are superior in technology and reliability these days yet we are seeing the domestic brands sans Chrysler begin to hold their own in the ratings and in the general opinion of the consumer.

Considering my personal experience with domestic brands I would never buy a Ford or Chrysler again but the recent reports from Consumer Union has me actually thinking I may look at domestic brands in the near future. I certainly want them to do well but I will not sacrifice my hard-earned money to buy something that will nickel-and-dime me constantly over the next ten years. Pretty soon you and Ford/GM will begin spouting CR ratings as evidence of how well American cars are made to appear credible to the average consumer.

Here is a bit of irony - I just got a survey request from Consumer Reports asking me to rate the annual Car Issue.....

Ed

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required