Is the Hummer "greener" than the Prius?

Jun 04, 2007 176 Replies

I disagree; the Hummer is an evolution of a design that was pretty well worked out around the time of WW2. The Prius uses technology that wasn't used on a wide scale in an automotive application until the introduction of the Prius, and wasn't even introduced by a major manufacturer prior to GM's EV-1.

For my money, were I buying a new car with environmental consciousness in mind (and, as I stated before, I couldn't justify buying a new car on environmental grounds unless my current ride was well and truly completely worn out) I would be looking at something like a Volkswagen TDI. VW has been building Diesels far longer than hybrids have been around, and VW has a known track record for longevity.

nate

You assume CO2 output is even the real issue.

Graham

To quote your words.....

**** " in an automotive application " ****. You're correct as far as that goes.

It's old tech anywhere else.

Do you think fuel injection is hi-tech too btw ?

Graham

The Peugeot diesels are the best I know of, although of course not available to you. I drove a compact Peugeot turbo diesel 1.9 litre back in '88 and it was remarkably brisk ! The sales rep was moderately impressed too. I actually couldn't tell it wasn't a gasoline engine other than the 4500 ? max rpm.

Graham

In message news: snipped-for-privacy@hotmail.com, Eeyore sprach forth the following:

You "fail to see" quite a lot of things, chimp.

In message news: snipped-for-privacy@hotmail.com, Eeyore sprach forth the following:

Look it up, chimp.

If you are speaking of "greener" then it is. Unless you mean greener as in money wise. Even then, if you were to replace the battery at 4 thousand dollars.. the cost is still better.

Has there ever been a production car in the past 50 years that was new- tech?

There are tech articles about the Prius at

formatting link
and
formatting link
(article #199200607), including a video of one being taken apart. The emphasis is mostly on the electronics, and the CPUs are dated 1995.

Just my impression of driving for 30+ years and having driven one for a little while.

No idea, can you use Google?

There's no proof that CO2 is causing global wrming, if that's what you mean. It's entirely conjecture.

Graham

Exactly. That's really old stuff in the world of electronics.

Even ideas like regenerative braking go back nearly a century.

Graham

I was hoping someone might know.

Google links to lots of sites that don't give a number but I did eventually find.....

6.8 MPG !

That's worse than a semi averages hauling a load !

Graham

There is nothing more to tell, based on my Opinion, and that's all I've got, I think that the Pirus will cost more in maintenance than the Hummer over the same period of time, not to mention that I think it will deteriorate more over the same period of time - and the comfort level is vastly different.

Why did you capitalize "opinion"??? You're falling apart, one Lego at a time.

Why do you feel the need to divert from the topic/subject in ever thread you post in?

Since YOU can't control how I PoSt, since you don't have HOPE of changING how I post, Why Don't You Troll Somewhere Else?

Gee whiz...I'm just curious. You're doing this strange capitalization thing today. I wondered if maybe you had a mild stroke.

It's certainly been around a lot longer than hybrid automobiles - 1955 (Mercedes-Benz/Bosch) or 1957 (Chevrolet/Rochester) depending on what side of the pond you're on. And that's not even counting race-only setups like Hilborn.

Sure there have been hybrid Diesel/electric locomotives for about that long, but the real challenge is scaling that technology down to work in a midsized-car application, and we still haven't been 100% succesful. I say that because the Prius is still heavier and slower than a comparable conventional vehicle.

nate

I'll have to take your word for it; the track record of French automakers in the US has been uniformly abysmal (and FIAT as well, for that matter.) Really the only European imports we get in any quantity are the German ones, and in fact I'm pretty sure that those are the only ones that have an official presence here save for Rolls-Royce and Bentley.

nate

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required