Man this topic is SUCH a Rage! I love it!
Anyhow, there's at least one bit more to octane use that some of you may not appreciate.
Given any car's altitude, its octane requirements will vary. A car at sea level will tend to require more octane than a car at 5000 feet above seal level. I wonder if all those people with Maximas that ping on regular (My 98 Max SE did it on 87 octane with enthusiastic throttle openings) live at or around sea level? I'm in the NYC area so that's pretty much sea level.
A Maxima owner who lives in, say Denver, may be fine on 87 octane.
So then, this discussion should include where the maxima owner lives and drives.
The Max owner who swears by 87 octane and has never heard a ping, do you live at sea level? Do you "get-on-it" as it were?
CD